Pitchfork is incapable of giving a respectable score to anything

412

lol what? I liked this album well enough, and really liked a few songs but this score is way too high.

171

i think they meant 0.79/10

131

That's a respectable score. I wanted more pop than country out of this album, but it's still pretty good even if it's not my favorite genre. I could see why others really like it tho, I probably would give it about a 6/10.

106

Pitchfork is wrong about everything. No way this is over a point better than Preacher’s Daughter

96

Flop

47

I’d probably give it like a 6/7 out of 10

30

That's way too high

28

it was more like a 5-6 but pop off

23

yea , sns was sm better than mbf by a long shot

15

I didn’t care much for the album except for House Tour, I’d rather listen to Short n Sweet, that album had actual bangers

9

This album deserves like a 4/10

8

The industry is trying to prop her up so hard lmao that album was ass

7

Might be a hot take but Sabrina Carpenter lacks actual substance in her music which is why she won’t be remembered post career compared to real music legends. Goes for Taylor too but her awful fanbase won’t let anyone forget that mediocre discography of hers😂

6

i just prefer some of her older stuff

5

Preacher’s Daughter got a 6.4…

4

If you know anything about pitchfork, 7.9 is a pretty decent score to get lmao

4

I get the criticism but it was still a fun little album 😭 saying that as someone who’s not a fan and didn’t rly like short n sweet that much. I think the expectations were way too high and i don’t get what’s so wrong with a 27 year old woman making a sex positive satirical break up album.

3

I'd give it a 6-7

2

Big news for the unemployed

2

7.9 is a very good score lol

1

This album is a grower. It was meh on first listen then by the third I really liked it. It’s more story less pop sing along

1

such a disappointment ngl but i should have known….

1

That’s at least 3 points too high

1

What did they rate mbdtf

1

this rating is diabolical.

1

i actually like this take

1

I feel like you have two categories of people. 1. Who didn’t like the vibe or genre of the entire album 2. The men she’s talking about in the songs

1

Better than Swimming by Mac Miller is CRAZY

1

Basically a 10 in pitchfork terms

-2