In all fairness, some of the questions are incredibly stupid. And I do get that that’s the point of the group and why it helps that you can ask them anonymously. But sometimes I feel like the questions are stupid on purpose; when we’re in willful ignorance or even ego stroking territory, I think it CAN be legitimately helpful to call it out so you have the chance to reflect and examine why you were ever in the position to ask it (or not but at least you have that chance)
I asked once about some dating advice I was always told as a kid (that when you start dating a guy you have to leave half your plate at restaurants for the first 3mo of dating) some ppl told me it wasn’t true, I asked here and got downvoted w a bunch of men telling me I’m an idiot😭like yall can be nice even if you think the question is stupid
Or the post asking if you guys would date a fat girl and #8 said on principle no as part of their answer. I’m chubby and ik everyone has preferences which is totally ok! But when we genuinely need help and this feels like the only safe place for us to ask questions, to be shut down in ways like that hurt
And yet, (at least for me, and for a lot I’ve seen on here) even when we directly call that stuff out, we still answer the question (if it is one) fully and as helpfully as possible as if we believed it was genuine (either in case it was, to humor you as a show of good faith, or just as a mental exercise). Which is pretty good, all things considered imo
Well did you want them to lie about the fat question? Or genuinely change as people to make the true answer better? Asking questions you dont want the answer to is kindof… not our fault (for what it’s worth, you’re prob in better shape than you think, most are, js) And yeah, the “ask women” version of that is dudes “asking” fetishes in (sort of) the form of a question. It’s bad enough they often won’t answer ANYTHING sex/dating related, even a clearly sincere question lol. Yeah, it’s an issue
Which I think is great! More ppl need to do that and some of your comments are really funny! I think that sometimes in the heat of the moment when we’re feeling low or just want a straight up answer, we come here. But straight up doesn’t also have to be mean! I see the humor in your comments though!
And I think that calling ppl on their bs is also needed! But sometimes just asking for clarification if you’re thinking about answering the question could also be helpful. Just taking it as you read it may not be their true intention behind the question! If you think it’s just a dumb question you can answer in a way that doesn’t also make us feel like shit for even asking
Most of the time yea I agree as well! I’m not trying to say that ALL of you guys aren’t answering in a helpful way and I’m really sorry if it’s coming off that way! But some of the guys in here answer in a way that makes us not want to ask for you help, that’s a huge purpose of this community!
I don’t think you’re ENTIRELY wrong by any means! If you see a question like that you could ignore it or be like if you have to ask you already know the answer. Sometimes that response is needed absolutely! But, most of us genuinely just want your help and don’t have people in our lives who will be honest without making us feel disgusting
Yes most ppl can control their weight, but there are so many other factors that play into it! The way in which some responded to that question was just, icky. And it’s not always unhealthy, obesity is absolutely unhealthy. But there r ppl who eat right, exercise, and take good care of themselves over all but have a LOT of difficulties actually losing the weight no matter what they do
You also have to take into account that not everyone will find that humorous. Plus online sarcasm and dry humor isn't always obvious, and i've never really seen you genuinely answer a question. I'm not saying what you're doing is wrong, but you can encourage people think about their questions in a kinder way. It literally cost nothing to be more considerate of people's feelings.
Just read some of the examples you gave: Men give blunt answers. This is how we actually talk to one another. We don’t butter stuff up. For example, the chubby question had multiple people saying yes and multiple saying fuck no. That’s called having a preference and you decided to highlight on the negative side even though there were people that said they do. The relationship question is kind of ridiculous. We are all humans and we all experience different types of emotions (unless -
they’re psychopaths). (Mb freestyle. Responded to the wrong comment) You will get a variety of answers and as this is an anonymous board, expect that most of the answers given are straightforward. Now I have 5 close girl friends that I let in my circle and they all tremendously appreciate my brutal honesty. If you get past the emotions and look at the response, we’re all just trying to help you become the best version of yourself.
This is actually a great point lol. Honestly I think that everyone in Ask Men and Ask Women could be nicer about it while getting their point across. It’s not a matter of “growing thicker skin”. Some ppl take this stuff really personally and you can’t blame them for that that’s just the way some people are
I would be… how did you put it? “Insensitive and degrading” in my response and, given the question, that would be 110% justified if that were a sincere question. Although, really, anyone who asks that probably just has a degradation kink and I’m now feeding it. But honestly? I can live with that. If that’s what she’s into, let that gal get her rocks off By the way, what is this a great example of? Questions we would answer rudely? True I guess, but it’s also a great example of WHY