
As a woman I personally wouldn’t be turned off but I can’t blame other women for wanting a man and being attracted to a man who’s strong enough and a good enough fighter to win a fight. Some women want protectors and if you lose a fight in front of them, nonetheless GET YOUR ASS BEAT you’re showing them that you aren’t strong enough to protect them when the time really comes to it. That said I don’t think it’s ridiculous that a woman would be turned off by that.
As a man I agree although I would argue brute physical strength isn’t the only aspect of a good protector. There’s also how much he’s willing to do to protect you. For example, I’m in a board game group at college that plays late at night. I’m usually the skinniest guy there, but unlike some of the more muscular guys, I usually offer to walk my close female friends back to their dorms, because I want them to both be safe and feel safe.
Like I said I don’t get turned off if my man looses a fight, but it’s completely natural and normal for a women to get a bit of an ick over a man loosing a fight. We are simply animals after all. Some women want strong men who win fights and that’s that. If you can’t win a fight either don’t get into them or find a woman who doesn’t mind that you’re not the strongest pick of the bunch.
I think if you’re takeaway is that it’s okay for your significant other to love you less because he tried to defend himself (or you) and failed, maybe it’s actually you (and everyone else who feels that way or thinks it is understandable to feel that way) who should stay single. But you’ll be glad to know that I will do as you wish, I will no longer be looking to date
You have to understand that most of the time when a woman sees her boyfriend get his ass beat, it’s because he’s being a loser who’s starting shit he can’t finish. Usually guys aren’t just attacked out of nowhere. There is a context for why this is repulsive and it’s not just about losing a fight