when a guy is too nice i always feel like i’m going to be too much for them. i like to be challenged and i like a confident man. if a guy is too nice i can almost guarantee that they will just do what i want all the time and always agree with me which sounds great but i need someone who has their own life, their own identity, and can challenge me and push me to continue to grow. also TOO nice early on tells me they want something else and i can’t do that either.
Ok when u phrase it likes this, when girls say he’s “too nice” it usually means they’ve got some deep insecurities and they don’t think they deserve someone that nice. There’s other reasons too, like if he’s just a pushover with no real goals, but he treats u really nice but just has no real personality, but that can also be true of women as well