Book Club on Yik Yak | Fourth Wing Hot Take: The concept could have been so much better if Violet was killed during training and Mira was/became the main character and found out about it.

Yik Yak

Download

Join communities on Yik Yak Download

Book Club 19h

Fourth Wing Hot Take: The concept could have been so much better if Violet was killed during training and Mira was/became the main character and found out about it.

Anonymous 17h

I was thinking it would have been much better if Violet stayed a scholar and just happened to bond with a dragon whilst uncovering secrets about the academy. Instead of the stupid war college, trials plotline.

Anonymous 19h

Sorry. I just hate Violet. "Mary Sue" is usually an unhelpful criticism since it's kind of broad and execution matters a lot, but Violet is THE Mary Sue. Never read such a Wattpad Hoover SJM book and FMC in my life.

Anonymous 12h

Love fourth wing

Anonymous 10h

So i actually think this could lowkey be fire, but i also think that thats just a different story (which tbf, probably the point). I can totally understand a book not being for you (recently been hit by like 3 DNF’s in a row). There’s definitely also something to be said about how even if that was the case, it could be the author thats the problem, not the story. I adore fourth wing, but i am a trash panda, I consume a lot of garbage books, so im not shocked it’s considered one by some.

Anonymous

#1 17h

YEAH, OR THIS ^^^

Anonymous

#2 12h

And that's valid!

Anonymous

OP 12h

Personally I don’t see what you all see but I’m glad we can admit that not all books are for everyone without shaming each other.

Anonymous

#2 12h

^^^ No one should be shamed over a book they like! I like stuff that other people love or that others hate. It's all up to taste! I just couldn't connect to Fourth Wing, but I understand how others may have connected with the book! I also like media that is objectively garbage in literally every way (i.e. the fanmade anime series on Youtube called Blood Raining Night, it's so bad that it's entertaining i have not let go of it since the pandemic in 2020).

Anonymous

OP 12h

*To clarify, I don't generally like "objectively" garbage media. Blood Raining Night just has a special place in my fucked up little heart because of how fucking insane it is.

Anonymous

OP 12h

Feel like that’s kinda me too. Like I like stuff that everyone says is bad or not good writing like fourth wing and zodiac academy. There’s been so much about both but I love both.