
I disagree. Otherwise it wouldn’t have been rated like another game that just came out today. There’s a reason it doesn’t have the same critic or user rating as the original game. For a hardcore fan, it’s arguably worse than the original game. For a casual fan, or someone not willing to adapt to 1998 game design, this new version is a very nice bridge being past and modern game design. It’s overall the best way to play the game for non-enthusiasts and should be reviewed as an independent game.
I don't disagree with any of your points but I do think those discussions only matter because we're here in a world where all modern 3D games were already shaped by Ocarina. It's an absurd hypothetical obviously, but if the Ocarina remake had just dropped on Steam one day in a world where it never came out in 1998, I don't think it would stand out in 2026 in the slightest. It's notable almost purely because of its relationship to a legendary game.
I don’t think you're considering how popular Zelda is as an IP. A new 3d Zelda game with graphics as good as Ocarina of Time Remake, and that hosts a more vibrant creative world than any of the Breath of the Wild games, and a soundtrack that feels nostalgic even if you’ve never heard it and really captures that adventurous vibe Zelda games are known for is doing well, even if the gameplay loop and design seems more rudimentary. And would likely be a contender at the game awards
I agree. There are people who have never played a Zelda game before that still love this remake as if it had just came out today. For someone like me whose played the original several times (I still have played the 3ds version) you can say it’s nostalgia. I don’t believe that means there aren’t people who are still able to enjoy it today even with modern “contenders”. At least in the 3d Zelda space thats actiona dventure