
saying this as someone who’s played all three games, i’d say: - go bananza if you loved mario odyssey and want an evolution of that formula! and if you love monke smashing things - go pokopia if you’re a big fan of pokemon, like cozy games, and enjoy good and witty writing! this game has a bit of a faster pace than say stardew or animal crossing but it doesn’t detract from the game at all. - go mkw if you have friends you can play mario kart with! it’s mario kart, what else to say lol
I borrowed a friend’s switch oled a few years back to play Mario Odyssey, and I absolutely loved it so I know I’d also probably love Bananza. So Pokopia probably wins out in replay value, while Bananza has the edge in terms of a complete, single-player narrative experience. I can’t decide 😭
Bananza was so good, but I haven’t played Pokopia so I can’t give you a good take. You might be able to find Bananza second hand for cheaper though if you’re willing to look for it later. I’d say it’s roughly a 30 hour game, with good side content, although it does get repetitive towards the end.
Yeah, Mario kart was a bit of a let down with the huge “open world” they added. I wish they prioritized single player in that game mode with more meaningful challenges or a story mode of some sorts. It’s still really good Mario kart during the races though. I could only enjoy the intermissions in knockout tour