Anonymous hermatcha 12w

“approved by God” well yes!

33

Anonymous #2 12w

she is!! her humor is so good

13

Anonymous #6 12w

choice feminism. intersectional feminism. women should have the choice to portray their sexuality as they choose 🤷‍♀️ sabrina carpenter is not the portrayal or voice of every woman

19

Anonymous #4 12w

perhaps

2

Anonymous cherryblossom.baby 12w

calling it feminism just bc it’s a choice doesnt make it feminist; not every performance of sexuality is empowering just bc a woman’s doing it

-5

Anonymous #6 12w

have you considered its empowering her? why do others need to feel empowered by someone else’s choices? especially their own performance of sexuality

25

Anonymous #6 12w

They’re hating but you’re right, choice feminism isn’t feminism at all

1

Anonymous #6 12w

I don’t think Sabrina carpenter had ever claimed to be a feminist so I’m not sure why people have been placing that label on her

9

Anonymous #9 12w

if you support women’s rights and freedom ur a feminist. everyone is a feminist and should be, it’s just the bare fuckikg minimum

17

Anonymous #9 12w

she is literally a feminist 😭

7

Anonymous #11 12w

In what way though…

2

Anonymous #10 12w

She’s not a feminist, quit trying to force that on her when she’s clearly not. Even if she did claim to be a feminist not every choice that a woman makes is inherently feminist just because a woman made it, that’s such a middle school level understanding of feminism. For ex, a woman could have made the free choice to vote for trump last November and might have felt empowered by it, but was it actually a feminist action? Nope! Same thing applies here even if it’s not exactly the same scenario.

-2

Anonymous #7 12w

i understand that, i know what you mean there’s no reason to be nasty about it.

4

Anonymous #7 12w

we aren’t talking about politics tho. it’s about basic shit like pro choice, work life or stay at home wife or mom or both, etc.

6

Anonymous #7 12w

but this is not any way similar to voting for trump. how is her direct choice affecting other women? how is this directly disempowering other women? she is not responsible for how men view her album or their actions because of it. she is not stripping women of their power. or saying women HAVE to be this way nor is she saying any other woman is this way other than herself. how is that inherently anti feminist.

3

Anonymous #10 12w

I think you underestimate how much politics has to do with our every day lives. We don’t live in a vacuum, the world around us influences all of our actions and some of those actions might not be “feminist” per se. I’m not saying anyone has to be perfectly feminist 100% of the time because nobody can ever be perfect, but we have to stop calling actions “feminist” based on the sole fact that it was done by a woman who says she feels “empowered” by it.

-2

Anonymous #10 12w

Sabrina’s album cover might have been “empowering” for her but calling it “feminist” is a stretch. Not saying we need to go out on a witch hunt after her for it but it helps no one to try and label it as “feminist”

2

Anonymous cherryblossom.baby 12w

It might not be a direct action that affects women but nonetheless we’re allowed to not be comfortable with an image that looks like stuff like this

6

Anonymous #7 12w

sure. no one has to be comfortable with anything. i think the key point here, imo is that sabrina has put herself in this position. the woman in this picture is bound to this man who is actively hitting her, and its her husband. this photo is actively stating that men should hit their wives for better coffee. sabrina’s album cover is not stating women or men should be treated a certain way, just her. its fine to be uncomfortable, but not fine to claim its setting all women back

-4

Anonymous cherryblossom.baby 12w

i also would like to say im not trying to claim sabrina is a feminist, thats her own belief system i have no clue about lol

-2

Anonymous #7 12w

i ain’t reading all that i just said one thing and that’s that. have a good one!

-1

Anonymous #12 12w

thanks for coming to my unsolicited ted talk 😌💅

2

Anonymous #12 12w

i live for unsolicited ted talks, thank you 💗

0

It wasn’t, you’ve been brainwashed by porn

4

Anonymous #12 12w

But why is femininity and sexuality synonymous with kneeling on the ground and being pulled by your hair to you? Everyone seems to think that female sexuality and submissiveness and sexual degradation are the same thing. They are not.

1

Anonymous #13 12w

first, sexuality* (in this case) refers to her personal sexuality. maybe that’s what she likes. her liking submissiveness and sexual degradation does not make her pride in her sexuality any less valid that the men who talk about being dominant. second, this is once again assuming that the cover isn’t some kind of satire or commentary

-1

Anonymous #12 12w

Her art lacks the depth and subversiveness necessary to pull off satire. If your satire lacks clarity of purpose, it’s not satire, you’re just engaging in whatever you’re claiming to satirize

8

Anonymous #13 12w

part of the art is the album itself, so you can’t make such a definitive claim that it isn’t satire until the music comes out, so we don’t truly know whether or not it’s satire and cannot knock that option out

2

Anonymous #10 12w

I think you’re describing a more egalitarian view, feminism is not just about securing rights and freedom for women but also believing that misogyny must be eliminated for our liberation. I don’t think she has made any statements about this nor has she written about this (to my knowledge; correct me if I’m wrong). All women are not inherently feminists. That being said, I don’t think she’s setting women back and if people really cared about feminism there are more important causes to focus on.

4

Anonymous #13 12w

I think you make a very good point here

4

Anonymous #13 12w

This is so unfair to say. Yk all the valid arguments made against the cover and u still INSIST only saying sh*t like this. The problem with the cover was never it being “sexy” it was people claiming crawling at the feet of a man was “satire” and “deep”. Her music is NOT deep enough for that cover down vote me into oblivion idc that’s my truth

0

Anonymous #9 12w

Right why be a feminist when u can just reap the benefits of feminism

5

Anonymous #12 12w

You Sabrina defenders keep getting the argument wrong🫩 it was never about her “expressing her sexuality”. Scroll up if u want to actually read the argument instead of making up ur own argument

-3

Anonymous #15 12w

i cant tell if this is sarcasm or not (genuinely)

0

Anonymous cherryblossom.baby 12w

We know.

0

Anonymous #10 12w

I can tell it might be a lot for someone with your brain size to process :(

0

Anonymous #16 12w

ok. weeeell if its not i feel like thats an entirely different conversation than assuming one woman (being herself & making decisions for herself) has the power to completely set back feminism. an important social/political belief system that (if im reading the comment right) should only be reserved for women who ‘deserve’ it? if carpenter isnt being a feminist woman correctly she doesnt deserve those benefits?

1

Anonymous #16 12w

The way some of you dictate what feminism should look like is the reason why feminism isn’t broadly looked at or acknowledged you just feed the patriarchy little do you know and the societal standards of how women express their sexual desire and femininity 🤨

5

Anonymous #8 12w

yes! women are actively dying of femicide around the world!

0

Anonymous #15 12w

No it’s supposed to be like a dog. That’s why there’s the dog with the collar on the other side. And the guy is holding her hair like a leash. Be so fr

11

Anonymous #17 12w

“Mans best friend” come on bro

11

Anonymous cherryblossom.baby 12w

How can u possibly not tell💀 ofc it’s sarcasm the whole reason she’s even allowed to have a job and make her own money is because of feminism but ur saying she isn’t a feminist which means she reaps the benefits of feminism fought for BY feminists while she herself doesn’t contribute to the fight💀 oh god how did u people get into college

4

Anonymous #18 12w

“Quit b*tching” yup I would expect that from a Sabrina d*ck rider 🫩 u people r sheep istg and the downvote warriors are the Sabrina defenders more than anyone else cause they can’t STAND that not all women have the same opinions

-2

Anonymous #15 12w

hit a nerve there i see…

5

Anonymous #15 12w

i never said she is or isnt… i said i dont know and im not going to claim whether she is or not? and that was at #7 who deleted their comments comparing sabrina’s album to a sexist ad of a husband hitting his wife, and said i was claiming she was a feminist. so i think my statement has gotten lost in the sauce.

1

Anonymous #15 12w

i figured it was sarcasm and wanted to double check, we’re on the internet 🤷‍♀️

1