
Even a criticism should still have examples or an argument behind it, so thank you. If you want to make the criticism stronger, you should start by showing precisely how those statements are shallow and false. I will agree with you that people who argue that way are missing the distinction and relation between gender and sex. I’ll explain that in another post, and make a better argument. I encourage you to criticize with a counter-argument if you feel up to it.
An actual argument would go more like this: If a trans-man is to be considered a real man, gender must take precedence over sex. A good way to determine if this is true by looking to definitions. Gender is a literary device that associates inanimate things to either a male or female sex. Sex is the result of physical characteristics that are rooted deep in the biology of a living being. Since gender requires sex to define it, gender cannot define, and therefore cannot take precedence over, sex.