Icks on Yik Yak | christians. so you're saying god incarnated himself into a guy who himself is also god, tortures himself in this form, and then sacrifices himself to himself to pay for the sins he allowed to happen.

Yik Yak

Download

Join communities on Yik Yak Download

Icks 16h

christians. so you're saying god incarnated himself into a guy who himself is also god, tortures himself in this form, and then sacrifices himself to himself to pay for the sins he allowed to happen.

Anonymous 9h

God is merciful. God is also just. Without free will there could be no willful love of god, but having free will means there is a capacity for sin and bad things to happen. If a candy bar costs 5$ and a kid eats the candy bar, they owe 5$. Similarly, if a person sins and the cost of sin is death, then the person owes their life. If a person ate no candy bars pays for the kids candy bar, the debt is resolved and paid for. Similarly if a man, Jesus, lived a sinless life, he can pay the cost ofsin

Anonymous 11h

dont forget that two members of EVERY species somehow managed to coordinate to get on a wooden boat in the middle east. the predators and prey somehow lived other in harmony. they somehow all had enough food to eat and water to drink. from anywhere between 40-400 days 😐😐😐 its the mental gymnastics for me😭

Anonymous

#1 10h

And furthermore: all the other animals DROWNED. Why are we worshipping a god that kills puppies and hamsters. Be so fr.

Anonymous

#2 10h

native americans and basically every other civilization not even noticing and not being wiped out by a "global flood" that "killed everyone" 😭😭😭

Anonymous

#3 9h

Hey I appreciate the good faith explanation but I’ve been reading the Bible for a class and I read about David’s story. David got to kill Bathsheba’s husband and got off scott free. In fact, he was blessed with a fruitful kingdom and powerful lineage. This part kind of ticked me off and I was curious about your thoughts

Anonymous

#3 9h

I’d love to have a conversation with anybody who shares a different perspective😊

Anonymous

#3 9h

Okay cool because to me it sounds like David went unpunished—perhaps even rewarded—for murdering an innocent man. Why that just in the eyes of god?

Anonymous

#2 9h

*why is that

Anonymous

#2 9h

I have no credentials so I understand taking what I have to say with a grain of salt, but in the Old Testament there are many examples like that where killing is forgiven and commanded. The journey of the Israelites out of Egypt was concluded with the conquering of Canaan through war. My explanation of this is that in the Old Testament, God made the Israelites his people, while the people of other nations followed different gods. Similarly, Uriah the Hittite was not an Israelite so he was not

Anonymous

#3 9h

One of gods people. It wasn’t until the coming of Jesus that people of all nations were declared gods people. I will not speak on reasoning or justification because truthfully I’m not sure and don’t want to give you an answer that I do not believe in, but this is my thought on the matter

Anonymous

#3 9h

No I think what you’re saying is really reasonable and kind of helps me understand Christian/jewish beliefs. I do wonder though, why would god (via Jesus) change his mind? Would that imply that god makes mistakes?

Anonymous

#2 9h

Look at 2 Samuel 11:11-18. I refamiliarized myself with the story. He was certainly punished for this.

Anonymous

#3 9h

Chapter 12**

Anonymous

#2 9h

I do not view Jesus as evidence of Gods mistake but rather evidence of his mercy. God gave us a covenant with him to follow to live in accordance with him, and littered all throughout the Old Testament is time and time again where humanity has failed and strayed from God. Even Moses did not follow Gods commandments and even Moses was punished for this by not getting to see the promised land he led the Israelites to. Because there was so much sin among humanity and no one that could live up to

Anonymous

#3 9h

The old covenant made, God made a new covenant through Jesus: that all who accept Jesus as lord and savior may not perish but have eternal life. God sent Jesus to earth to lead a blameless life, show humanity its shortcomings and how to live in accordance with God, then was sacrificed to pay the debt humanity incurred and fulfill the new covenant in him.

Anonymous

#2 9h

Btw I respect the civil discourse here👊

Anonymous

#3 9h

But changing the covenant to accommodate for others is still an instance of god changing his mind. I was under the impression that god was supposed to be omniscient and all-knowing. Is this not god being like “yknow what I was wrong about humanity, let me switch things up”? And wouldn’t that mean he made a mistake that he was correcting?

Anonymous

#1 9h

Funny you say that when other mythologies from that time period also have a flood origin story So thanks

Anonymous

#2 9h

He is. In the Old Testament he outlined what a moral life was and was not, and gave humanity the knowledge that the wages of sin were death. He didn’t change the covenant he made a new one. I know that sounds semantic but it isn’t. The Bible is a lot of baby talk to point to a few key things, that there is a creator of the universe who made humans in his image, that humanity took this for granted and turned to sin, that God could not let sin go unpunished, but had mercy on humanity so he sent

Anonymous

#3 9h

Jesus to cover the cost of humanity’s sin, and that because of Jesus, we are saved from dying in our sin. I will not speak on Gods timing or Gods plan, but these are what are at work in the time between the old and New Testament, and I wish I had a more complete answer for you, but all I know is that I am a sinner and Christ is my savior, and that God knows more than I. I have only been Christian for 2 years now, it’s a lifetime journey to understand more completely, so please excuse me for that

Anonymous

#4 9h

flood stories exist. if you read my comment, i never said stories didn't exist. i just said that they didnt wipe out all of humanity and they didn't happen everywhere like the bible says

Anonymous

#2 8h

In 2 Samuel chapter 12 he was cursed because he sinned but God kept his promise for his lineage. Since he did that his son died, and I wouldn’t consider that scott free, but the covenant was upheld and he was able to continue his lineage. I can see how you could see it as him not getting punished but I would argue that he had a worse punishment than death.