Anonymous #2 1w

It’s not Jewish. It reminds me of the time they copy pasted Hebrew using an English keyboard and it came out backward

20

Anonymous #3 1w

I’m sorry are you the pope of the Jews? Why do you get to decide that?

-7

Anonymous #2 1w

Hebrew has been written the same way for thousands of years? What? I’m genuinely confused by this comment. What are you even angry about?

17

Anonymous #1 1w

I’ll ask you the same question

-6

Anonymous #2 1w

I genuinely don’t understand your question. It doesn’t make any sense in the context of the post or comments.

14

Anonymous #1 1w

It does make sense, if you have English comprehension skills

-4

Anonymous #2 1w

No it literally doesn’t. It sounds like you are asking if how Hebrew is written is up to interpretation? That makes no sense. It’s a language that’s written a certain way. Would you read English like hsilgnE?

9

Anonymous #1 1w

Ok I’ll rephrase that for ESL’rs. Why is it not jewish? Are you the pope of the Jews? Why do you get to decide that?

-6

Anonymous #2 1w

Any practicing Jew writing Hebrew especially for a Seder plate would know the direction Hebrew is written. Also Jews don’t have a pope. We have hundreds of years of tradition that any practicing Jew would know.

18

Anonymous #1 1w

Most American Jews don’t read or speak Hebrew. And yes you finally understood the question. We don’t have a pope so you don’t get to decide what is and isn’t Jewish just cause you disagree with their political perspective

-6

Anonymous #2 1w

The majority of American Jews don’t speak modern Hebrew, but in no way do the majority not practice Judaism with Hebrew prayers or readings of the Torah in Hebrew. All that image with the backwards Hebrew shows me is someone who has no understanding of Passover or Hebrew or Judaism, decided to google some words and smack it on a sheet to look more Jewish. It’s dumb. Defending the co opting of Jewish culture to makes political point is dumb.

20

Anonymous #1 1w

Yeah most people don’t actually commit to the full practice bruh. I don’t care about what your line in the sand is.

-7

Anonymous #2 1w

Most American Jews that actually observe Jewish customs have at least a basic understanding of the language. It doesn’t take a genius to understand how these people are trying to pervert Jewish customs to adhere to their agenda.

14

Anonymous #4 1w

Were Jewish labor bunds perverting the practice?

-6

Anonymous #2 1w

If people don’t commit to the full practice, why invoke imagery of the practice to make a political statement.

19

Anonymous #1 1w

To show that a state that claims to represent them doesn’t.

-4

Anonymous #2 1w

That makes zero sense

17

Anonymous #1 1w

Maybe if you’re lost in the sauce.

-5

Anonymous #2 1w

this thread makes no sense bc YOU r lost in JVPs sauce. why troll here

25

Anonymous #5 1w

The JVP “sauce”

-6

Anonymous #2 1w

The issue isn’t their political stance, the issue is their false piety and their misappropriation of Jewish tradition that they clearly do not know or respect

14

Anonymous OP 1w

Sure buddy keep crying in the comments whenever you get some pushback instead of having an open mind.

-2

Anonymous #2 1w

Someone needs to go back to Hebrew school 😭

13

Anonymous #3 1w

Ok 👍

-3

Anonymous #3 1w

Honest question cause I did go volunteer at my Zionist synagogue weekly through out high school. Was Hebrew school supposed to teach me that Palestinians are inherently violent or something racist like that?

-4

Anonymous #2 1w

No.

9

Anonymous #3 1w

Ok so what’s the point? Brush up on my alef bet for a language I see no practical use in learning except to make fun of Zionists with?

-5

Anonymous #2 1w

But it was supposed to teach you that you can’t just change the Haggadah to co-opt it for your leftist politics. Also you can be a Zionist and think Israel is crossing boundaries

16

Anonymous #2 1w

Realistically they would make fun of you… your language skills don’t seem so strong

12

Anonymous #3 1w

1.Jewish traditions have always evolved and changed throughout time according to the time and place. 2.And yeah you can be but you don’t understand what Zionism is. Maybe go listen to the victims of Zionism if you care about learning

-6

Anonymous #3 1w

I may not have the same vernacular you do not care about grammar rules in a chatroom. But I at least know I have better comprehension and critical thinking skills than you do.

-3

Anonymous #2 1w

*nor care

-2

Anonymous #2 1w

Tradition evolves in response to the needs of the community in order to better serve HKBH, not the idol of political opinion

13

Anonymous #2 1w

Passover is about the LAND of Israel, you know, the place Jews are from. Why are you so desperately trying to make it about the modern state of Israel? Is that just your coping mechanism when it comes to confronting the fact that Jews are native to that land?

9

Anonymous #4 1w

I believe that the photo we’re referencing was taken during the height of the encampments back in 2024. It also happened to align with Passover…

-2

Anonymous #6 1w

The idol of political opinion? Never heard that before are we coining new terms?

-1

Anonymous #6 1w

I think the idea that there is only one true god (hakadosh Baruch hu) and it’s ours is a little more in line with having a false idol than what I’m saying, no?

-1

Anonymous #2 1w

Bro isn’t Jewish but still wants a seder, lmao

13

Anonymous #6 1w

I am Jewish; culturally at least at this point in my life and was raised by a former Orthodox Jew who was president of my synagogue… but keep coping as if people don’t have the capacity to change their minds

-2

Anonymous #2 1w

So close, the belief in one G-d, The Lord of Hosts, G-d of Israel, The Holy One, Blessed be He, is not idolatry, but actually the core tenant of the faith

7

Anonymous #6 1w

Ok that’s fine for you I guess. It just shouldn’t be enforced.

1

Anonymous #2 1w

No. Rather, YOU should not be having a Seder as a political statement if you believe the core tenants of the faith to be idolatry

7

Anonymous #6 1w

See I don’t believe in tenants. It’s kind of what Reform Judaism is about. But I guess those are fake Jews according to you.

-1

Anonymous #2 1w

Most reform Jews aren’t like you. You may not be a fake Jew, but you certainly practice false Judaism. You’ve sacrificed all that is good and holy about our faith on the altar of Politics and brought tradition as a Olah of pleasing odor to your cause

11

Anonymous #7 6d

Bro can we have like one space for Jewish pride without accusing of colonialism

0

Anonymous #8 6d

This post is literally about that?

6

Anonymous #8 4d

If we’re talking about JVP we kinda have to talk about colonialism..

0

Anonymous #3 4d

I mean like lots of American Jews can’t read Hebrew

1