
But that IS a privilege to be in a straight relationship, what isn’t clicking? Its inherently safer and therefore a privilege over people who cannot and won’t choose to be in a heterosexual relationship. A bi man in a gay relationship is more oppressed than a bi man in a straight relationship because of the way he is perceived. Its literally about how society views same sex relationships and being hetero presenting is a privilege.
No. No we cant. Did you just tell me, a lesbian, i can he in a straight relationship? Youre literally just wrong. Same sex exclusive attracted people do not have the option to be in a straight presenting relationship without sacrificing their integrity so get over yourself. I got hit with a rock while holding hands with my girlfriend in the South. Do you get hit with rocks while in a relationship with men?
And fuck not everyone has supporting parents especially some of us who are from the red states don’t have that privilege and tho I’m glad my parents don’t care I’m bi I really believe it is because they’ll like “well as long as he still likes women meh” which I wouldn’t be surprised if that’s why some conservative families tolerate their bi children
This is crazy how youre circling back to being gay is a choice in attempt to prove your shitty point. Imagine if i put you in a relationship without sacrificing their a creepy guy you hate and you feel no attraction to. Thats not a choice for you is it? Because you aren’t attracted to him.
I'm not telling anybody to be straight, I'm saying everybody chooses their partner. When you're genuinely unsafe in your sexuality you'll be single or secretive before you're just openly in a gay relationship. It is a privilege to be safe enough to be openly queer. That is the point being made in this post
Yes. People marry their friends all the time. People marry people they're not attracted to all the time. Not everyone is in some crisis about their sexuality where they'd rather be dead than in a relationship that's not ideal. Anyways we're getting away from the point, the point of the post is that being safe in your sexuality is a privilege
You're literally missing the point of the post. It's about people who are safe in their sexuality vs people who are not. Not everyone who is a lesbian is unsafe just because they're a lesbian. People live in different places and come from different families. My cousins dad shot and killed him because he dated a trans woman. Has your dad ever tried to kill you for dating a woman?
No, I'm not ignoring it because this post isn't about all lesbians it is explicitly about lesbians who are supported and safe claiming to be worse off than other queer people who are actually in danger. If you are actually in danger because of your sexuality, then this post isn't about you.
My dad is dead and my only remaining family members are my 80 year old grandparents. Im a lesbian dating a trans woman. I live in LOUISIANA. Do you think im more privileged than you? No. You will never be able to understand not having the CHOICE to feel safe in a relationship and thats okay. You have the choice. I don’t.
Why are you acting like marrying a friend that you love and who would be a good partner to you would kill you just because that friend is a man? And why do you also act like "sacrificing your identity" is a huge dramatic thing for everyone? Not everyone holds their sexuality at the core of their being, a lot of people have other priorities in life
I'm not advocating for anything, I'm saying you don't have a gun to your head assigning a life partner and when you choose a partner based on what you value most. If you value being a lesbian more than anything else you'd probably choose a woman who treats you like shit over a man who's great in every aspect except that he's a man. I personally just value a person and what they have to contribute to my life more than I value taking claim to a word
Literally like god forbid we don’t want the additional trauma that comes with forcing yourself to violate your own sexual boundaries, I dont think OP has the ability to understand since they are attracted to people regardless of gender but if you talk to any purple heart lesbian those experiences were traumatic even tho they were *technically* consensual, its just fundamentally a different experience than being with someone you’re simply not that attracted to
Being gay isn’t a fucking choice… if it is then you are either bi or pansexual or whatever but not gay or lesbian idk who needs to beat this across your head because either you are too closed minded to understand nuance of different experiences or your a ragebaiter which I hope your the latter
I'm saying anyone can be happy and fulfilled in a relationship where they are loved and treated well by a partner they love even if the sexual attraction is not there. A lesbian who's divorced from an abusive partner was not inherently happier than a lesbian who prioritized true partnership over a romcom romance. That's the only point I'm making lol not everybody is destined for doom and gloom just because they marry someone who's not the romantic love of their life
I've said multiple times anyone can be fulfilled by a partner that treats them well and loves them and that they love. Sorry that you put the whole romance thing on an unearned pedestal, I just fundamentally disagree that every other type of love is invalid and you'll never be happy or fulfilled if you don't find some incredible romance. Being in love isn't what keeps couples together, being a good partner is what does
Hahahahaha you know why I put the romance thing on a pedestal bc I thought I was bi for the longest time and then I realized wait a second the reason I’m so miserable is bc I’m dating ppl who I’m not attracted to. Since I stopped trying to force myself into relationships with men, guess what I no longer think about offing myself all the time
Women exclusively attracted to women. The lesbians might kill me for excluding nonbinary people and trans men in that definition but let's keep it simple. So where in "women exclusively attracted to women" does that mean you have zero autonomy to choose a partner that doesn't align to your sexuality if you thought that was worth doing? Is every lesbian invalid a "straight" relationship because they prioritize their safety and not being ostracized over an identity invalid?
The point is getting offended over people not believing your gender is exactly the same as you telling lesbians and gay men we can be happily fulfilled in a straight relationship when it is antithetical to who were are. Asking people what their gender is and not respecting the boundaries they have is the same as not respecting sexualities.
Having sex with a man made me want to commit suicide the few times i did it. It is that serious. Being with a man made me want to jump off a cliff. It is THAT serious. If you’re actually a bi woman, i understand that doesn’t make sense to you bur STFU telling lesbians about OUR sexuality when you BARELY understand yours.
You don't have to have kids if you don't want to and if you want to, I'm not understanding what wanting kids has to do with your sexuality. Do you just really really want to get pregnant via sperm donor and don't wanna "sacrifice" that experience? You're losing me on that point. And on sex, not wanting to have sex with your partner is a problem any couple could face. I think if even an ace person can have sex occasionally because they love their partner, it's not insane to think others could too
Why do you make the assertion that the only way it could be traumatic to have sex with someone you don't want to have sex with is only applicable if you're a lesbian having sex with a man and why do you assert that it is inherently traumatic for every lesbian when it really is just an inconvenience practically for a lot of lesbians who were in comphet relationships?
Im talking about how you said it isn’t the end of the world to sacrifice my identity. It is to lesbians. This is why lesbians dont want to date you. YOU are literally the problematic bisexual that gives literally every other bi person a bad wrap. Bi people are wonderful and you will never represent them.
I also am not telling you about your sexuality lol I'm literally just saying there are millions of lesbians in the world who choose to date men because they value their safety more than laying claim to an identity. You are not less privileged because you're free enough to choose to date women
Like fuck though he was a cis gay man Frederick the great of Prussia wanted to end his life after he was forced to witness the beheading of his lover and hated having to pretend to be straight for his abusive father especially marrying a woman he did not love and eventually moved her out once he became king
Do you know every lesbian? You've asked every single one who's had sex with a man if it was traumatizing? You know it as a universal truth that an inherent feature of lesbianism is being traumatized by straight sex? Are all the lesbians who had a bf before understanding their sexuality and weren't traumatized but just not into it not considered lesbians?
I actually haven't downplayed a single one of you because I haven't said anything specific to you or about you. My sentiments are generally applicable. If you wanna take personal offense to something that might not even apply you you, especially when I've explicitly stated who it applies to, that's your own problem
I didn't call comphet an inconvenience I said having sex with a man isn't inherently traumatic to every lesbian and to some it's more of an inconvenience than anything else. Which is true. Not every former comphet lesbian goes into crisis at the thought of having had sex with her high school boyfriend. You're not even engaging with the conversation in good faith if you're gonna pretend that's not true
That's not minimizing you being suicidal lol it's pointing out that you were literally bi and could fully just choose not to have sex with men and that wouldn't even be imposing limitations on yourself. You don't have to choose to do things that you hate doing especially if you already had the hard part of figuring out you were queer sorted out
I thought I was bi, I was not bi. I thought I was bi bc of comphet. I knew I liked women but I had this idea that I could be happy in a straight relationships so I quite literally was trying to force myself to be straight for safety. It made me so miserable I was suicidal and that’s what you don’t get
Point being even if you thought you were bi you could exclusively have sex with women as a bi person. In any case, not everyone who is in comphet relationships is suicidal some people just figure it out and go on with their lives accordingly, that's not intrinsic to comphet relationships. A lot of people relate to your experience obviously but that's not THE experience, everybody has their own path to things
Do you know *any* lesbians that would refer to their experience with comphet (which would be the experience you’re describing there) as just an inconvenience to them? im saying it is inherently traumatic for lesbians, sure theres varying degrees to that but that goes for all trauma and oppression, you wouldn’t say someone getting kicked out for being queer is just an inconvenience for them because they coped well with it, you’re the one arguing in bad faith here,
Sex with men is an inconvenience. "It" is referring to sex with men, not comphet. This isn't even a case of ambiguous pronouns, the preceding thing that "it" refers to is "sex with a man". Again, this is a literacy issue. If you wanna argue that for some lesbians who has sex with men and weren't particularly into it while it happened but aren't in crisis about it aren't actually lesbians because a real lesbian would be suffering at the thought, you can make that argument I guess
Yes I know at least 2 lesbians who are still good friends with the first bfs and maybe the would or wouldn't use the word inconvenience but they have said that it wasn't that deep they just weren't really into it and didn't even know they were lesbian until they were with a woman and it felt completely different. A good amount of comphet lesbians do indeed just feel an indifference toward straight sex and they just wouldn't do it again but it doesn't kill them to know that they did
You can't ask me for personal anecdotes then say I can't use personal anecdotes. I never claimed the 2 people who vocally said this are representative of the entire lesbian population, I am simply arguing against the claim that it is intrinsic to lesbianism to be traumatized by the process of figuring out your sexuality and citing 2 people *that I was asked to cite* to support my claim. Those 2 people aren't representative of all lesbians but neither are you lol you're making my point for me
Duh this doesn’t remove the oppression that we face, theres lesbians that have never experienced this, though this started as a discussion about privilege not what being a lesbian is, no where did I say the trauma im describing is a “core” lesbian experience but that we shouldn’t reduce it to an “inconvenience” because we’re resilient,
Yeah so let's get back to the initial point of the conversation. About privilege. First of all I never said lesbians don't face oppression. The claim being made is a lesbian in a supportive environment who is free to live their life as they choose is not less privileged than a bisexual that is in a relationship with because their safety is actively at risk and it may even be a crime for them to be with a woman.
I'm not claiming all bisexuals are less privileged than lesbians, I'm claiming a western lesbian in a blue city who goes to a lesbian bar every weekend and is openly out and still supported by their family is not less privileged than someone who has to deny themselves on the basis of their sexuality due to where they are. It is not a strictly lesbian phenomenon and you are not inherently worse off because "in theory" you'd have to do that too if you lived where they lived
Your personal anecdotes don’t even prove your point? Like i said you can be friends with an ex bf as a lesbian and still feel a certain type of way about the sex/relationship, the only thing you proved is that we don’t hold it against the guys for society imposing comphet, doesn’t make it less oppressive or traumatic tho,
The way that you framed this absolutely does imply that though, this started with ppl in the comments saying that there is an additional additional consequences that come with choosing to be with someone that doesn’t match up with your sexual orientation, forgive me if im wrong but no one was saying bisexuals are inherently more privileged, just that we have different areas of privilege, and when people starting arguing with you you got defensive and reduced that to lesbians being superficial
The anecdote literally says "they have said that it wasn't that deep and they just weren't really into it and didn't even know they were lesbian until they were with a woman and it felt completely different" Like it literally says that they said it wasn't that deep that just weren't really into it and it was so inconsequential that they didn't even know they were a lesbian until they found out how you're supposed to feel when you actually are into it
People literally are saying bisexuals are inherently more privileged than lesbians in this thread. And I didn't reduce the additional consequences to being superficial, someone said lesbians CANT be happy with a man and I was simply arguing if you literally value anything about a partner beyond your attraction to them then you CAN be happy if they're giving you everything else you want/need from them. I do think it's superficial to die on the hill that you CANT be happy in a loving relationship
I never said lesbians are inherently worse off than other queer people, especially those that face other intersectionalities than lets say a cis white middleclass lesbian would, intersectionality is essential to my perspective as well, this includes the fact that lesbians do have a harder time having a beard of sorts than those that are capable of being attracted to the opposite sex, of course biphobia also sucks
Okay cool that *you* didn't say that, I never said that *you* said it. My post literally says "your mom goes to pride with you. I personally don't think someone opting for a straight relationship to avoid being beaten and murdered by their family is less privileged than you" If you agree with that sentiment, which this comment suggests you do, why did you come under this post arguing?
Lesbians have it worse in certain ways. No one was saying bi people don’t have their own oppressions and people being homophobic to them. But we all have unique privileges and being able to pass as straight is one them. Lesbians and gay men just dont have that privilege without sacrificing ourselves and identities. You have spent hours saying lesbians can be fulfilled in straight relationships which basically implies we can be fixed. You are lesbophobic and homophobic.
The way you were talking about this earlier gave the impression that we could just be happy in relationships with men and properly assimilate with little inconvenience, I think thats why people are accusing you of being a man into “dyke breaking” unfortunately thats another one of those things that we as lesbians have to be on the alert for as its a very dangerous homophobic fetish that targets us directly
I never compared it to losing attraction over time. I said you can be happy with a partner you're not attracted to. It is not a prerequisite for happiness that you MUST have been physically attracted to them when you met them. A nonnegotiable incompatibility to you is not a nonnegotiable to all. That's why you have some lesbians not figuring out they're lesbian until they're 40, and in the same vein why you have asexuals in relationships with people who aren't ace. People figure things out
You're missing the point continually. Do you think a lesbian who's publicly lesbian and out to her family and in community with a bunch of other lesbians and queer people is less privileged than a bisexual actively enduring physical violence and legitimate threats against her life? I'm not talking about theory and systems, I'm talking about real life comparing those two situations
I agreed with the post, but I disagreed with your comments you said about how lesbians (and yes lesbians abroad feel this way too) are pressured to ignore their own sexual boundaries in ways that bisexuals dont have to, its only one facet of oppression, but its a valid criticism, you took it as me saying its somehow the only way to have traumatic sex or that every lesbian experienced that, but thats not at all what I was saying
I didn't base that on my friends experiences nor did I say people "negotiate with their sexuality", your sexuality is what it is. I'm saying if you care more about a good partner who would be a good parent and who has your same values etc than you care about the idea of having sex with them, then it's not as much of a nonnegotiable as it is for someone that that's the primary concern. Gets back to the whole it's not always traumatizing some people are just not into it
If you're monogamous but your partner who's otherwise a great partner and supports the lifestyle you want and is a great parent and you guys work well together etc, the cost of becoming nonmonogamous may not be as high as a the benefit of staying with your partner. everyone runs cost benefit analysis and if the benefit exceeds the cost, it's worth it. To some people, nonmonogamy is a nonstarter and even suggesting it would end the relationship. To others, they're not a fan but not as averse
Talking about having to violate your sexual boundaries in order to please your family in response to my post reads as saying you are less privileged because bi people don't have to do that. My point is if you're safe enough to just decide you're not gonna conform to what's expected of you, you are not less privileged that a person who has no choice but to either conform or be brutalized and/or murdered. The first comment is bean souping sure, the second one is relevant
The second part was added later also, but im sorry my comments made you feel that I was trying to dismiss the invalidation that comes with biphobia, I was adding more nuance as a lesbian that has been on that end of it, that I can relate and how much it really sucks no matter what you do fr,