Anonymous #2 4d

Generally yeah.

49

Anonymous OP 4d

Why

-14

Anonymous #2 4d

You give money to person who hates a certain group of people and uses that money to oppress them = you by proxy supporting that behavior and funding it. Surely its not that hard to understand.

52

Anonymous #3 4d

dawg this isnt an opinion, this is fact

27

Anonymous #4 4d

So is ur momma

-13

Anonymous #3 4d

Do you have anyone who genuinely cares for you?

27

Anonymous #4 4d

Your dad

-14

Anonymous #3 4d

So, no, you dont

31

Anonymous #4 4d

I don’t know he seems to care a lot if you get my drift

-14

Anonymous #3 4d

This is cringe dawg

40

Anonymous #3 4d

do you feel desperate for attention? is that why you’re like this?

40

Anonymous #4 4d

Bro, you’re desperate for me to care

-11

Anonymous #3 4d

im desperate for you to touch grass

26

Anonymous #4 4d

I’m literally rolling in it right now fym

-11

Anonymous #3 4d

Rolling in dog shit maybe

38

Anonymous OP 4d

No baby girl, I’m rolling in your shit

-11

Anonymous #3 4d

And is that a supposed to be you winning?

36

Anonymous OP 4d

It could be whatever you want

-10

Anonymous #3 4d

This might be one of the worst comebacks i have ever heard. Oh my fucking god this is hilarious

41

Anonymous #4 4d

I think dude just wants the last word tbh

30

Anonymous #1 3d

Is that second part not a separation of the artist from their work? It is to me, and that's what I do. I love a lore of frankly shitty things by shitty people, and I just cut out the bad things and acknowledge how shitty it was. I think that's enough. (And don't give financial/moral support to them but that's obvious)

5

Anonymous #7 3d

love a lot*

1

Anonymous #7 3d

You cant just cut the bad things out. the bad things are a part. Like in harry potter for, making the goblins bankers, making a creature thats a “happy slave”, most of the evil women in hp being described as manish and spying on children

21

Anonymous #4 3d

that's just not true??? I don't really care for Harry potter, but if you were to write, like, a hp fanfiction you could just... not include that? Or rewrite them? Or even write the characters addressing and fixing the issues?? I see it more as these medias having potential than being good. The bad artists beliefs make it bad, but that doesn't mean there aren't good ideas within that have to be trashed. This isn't even to mention much smaller projects that would be much easier to "fix."

-2

Anonymous #7 3d

Hey friend— can you separate this art piece from its artist? Hitler painted it and when he later went onto to attempt to get into art school he was rejected. The reason i make this comparison is because this painting cannot ever be separated from its connection to hitler. Im not saying JK rowling is hitler (i am tho lowkey) but the painting has to be understood in the context of its creator and cant be understood any other way.

8

Anonymous OP 3d

Ok, I think we just have different views of what it even means. I don't think we should NOT consider the artist and acknowledge the context, especially if they did something horrible. I just think it doesn't mean you can never enjoy it or pull something good from it. Hogwarts is fun. Quidditch is fun. I understand that, you should be allowed to enjoy that, and you aren't a horrible person for it, as long as you acknowledge the creator is problematic. That's all I mean.

-1

Anonymous OP 3d

As for the painting, I don't know much about traditional painting but like, you could say "that's a good technique for painting trees" and use it in your work without being racist or loving hitler. I don't think the way he painted trees reflected his hatred for Jews. That is my version of separating the art and the artist.

0

Anonymous #7 3d

The difference is you cannot have any productive or deep conversation with a piece of art or media without discussing context. I have a masters in history and it is impossible to fully understand and interpret some source without understanding the context of the author. And sure you can enjoy it, no one is stopping you. But the baggage of the context is there and is intwined with the art whether you like it or not. I mean fuck— kingsley shacklebolt, the irish character whos constantly exploding?

7

Anonymous #7 3d

These are examples of the context of JK rowlings prejudice that is deeply intwined the book. Any deep understanding of any piece of media requires analysis of its historical context and significance.

11

Anonymous OP 3d

I mean, yeah, I agree. That's the same thing I'm saying. I just don't care and don't think anyone should care if you like something made by a shitty person as long as you are aware they're shitty and aware of how it reflects in their work. I don't get the point you're trying to make atp. Do you think it's morally wrong to ever enjoy something made by someone problematic??

1

Anonymous #4 1d

lol u suck

0

Anonymous #3 1d

Bro took 3 days to come up with something

1

Anonymous OP 1d

I don’t think anyone on this app should be acting like they’re the arbiter of what’s morally right and wrong. The world isn’t black white and people aren’t bad just because they separated the art from the artist and you didn’t. Maybe you should try to get off your pedestal once in a while.

-1

Anonymous OP 1d

Nahh I was just busy with your mom

-2

Anonymous #6 1d

THIS. but no one actually wants to respond to the valid criticism. they just wanna be right smh

-2