May be a little ignorant here, but what is it that specifically white trans people do to affirm their gender? I see it in other ways, aave has definitely been co-opted by the white queer community. For clarification, it’s the gender affirming parts that’s confusing me, either way I agree that cultural appropriation is shitty and needs to stop
I’m just asking for an opinion on this becuase I’ve had people say differing things. As a person who isn’t black am I still able to use aave? I’ve heard some people say no and it’s racist but, I know its aave but it is also just things people around me say all the time so idk, this might be the dumbest question in the world
Hiphop is a black genre of music stemming from our culture, but we were seen as thugs or rachet or ghetto when we wore it. Suddenly white people start to dress like us and call it “streetwear” thus appropriating a culture they demonized black people for that’s why I don’t like when white people dress in that style
Dykes and Studs have different connotations as to what racial group they belong to. Personally, when I think of dykes I think of white people and studs I think of black lesbians. I feel like a lot of hey mamas lesbians, who don’t grow up around Black culture btw, cop black culture by trying to wear clothing that typically reflect Black men. It’s just interesting when they’ve never acted like that and they easily have the ability to take off this costume and can pass as a different kind of queer
Oh no, that’s not what we’re gonna do. Just because it’s pride month doesn’t mean that queer people should just be allowed to get away with cultural appropriation. Criticism is allowed and okay. There is good reason and that is not being an asshole. Staying informed is important and being part of a marginalized community, that should be clear to you
Whats clear is that this gatekeepig causes division and seems to be a one way street. Should yt ppl be allowed to ‘feel unsafe’ if black folkx trans or otherwise wear French tip nails? Or lululemon and polos? Is sterling silver only for yts? Hb platinum? There is clear cultural appropriation and inappropriate use of dialects but sometimes it’s stretch and u only seem to be focused on trans ppl which is weird2 me
I LITERALLY mentioned the Asian influence in the nails (I didn’t know off the top of my head if ONLY Vietnamese people were part of it so I said Asian). I never said loud jewelry NOR wife beaters I listed specifically pieces of MY culture. And I specified trans people because I am also trans and have noticed this within my community (but now it is not solely a trans thing)
Maybe idk because at a certain point these are the same arguments people who promoted segregation made. Hiphop and stuff like that have been made as a bridge to unite people in the country and the natural consequences of that are various elements spread to Hispanics, whites, Asians etc. and also the other direction too! There is bad faith appropriation but there is also people just trying to show appreciation or integrate with their community. And the targeting of trans women made me want to—
So it started with Vietnamese people but it’s only a problem when white people also go to their nail salons? Make it make sense. Also the modern manicure also existed in Europe 🙀. The Vietnamese (which I am in part) don’t gate keep but you only say that it’s been shared before white people did it? Do you have any actual source for this or justvibes?
I believe my use of the word “shared” is causing you confusion. I say shared as in it was part of multiple cultures, not that the Vietnamese (who your saying started nail art even though there are traces of nail art dating back to ancient Egypt and ancient China if you wanna get real specific) went around the world showing off their cool designs to everyone
They popularized it when the southern Vietnamese immigrated here after communists took over Vietnam which is why somany Vietnamese live here in US. And I don’t think you want to play (your saying____but it really started ____) format game dude because everything can be discredited that way and I won’t do that to your culture so why u try to say China was first??? Doy know history that Vietnam was incorportated to ancient empires at various times?
I fully agree. I think what I misunderstood is our ideas of what the labels mean. Personally hey mamas white lesbians are not in the category of d¥ke or butch to me, as many call themselves masc, and I don’t like how they take from black culture so heavily and play it off as something they came up with and almost stereotype studs and black men while doing it, so I agree with you fully on that. I was trying to call out #7 as their statement seemed to be “do studs who act like d¥kes (lesbians)
Scare you too” and I understood what you meant by white lesbians acting like studs but thought #7 was being really weird and kidna saying that studs aren’t as lesbian as white lesbians as d¥ke can be a word for any lesbian. I fully agree that a lot of white lesbians take from black culture and do it to a really weird degree that I can’t find the right words for
So regarding hip hop fashion and street wear would you say it’s certain brands that are more problematic or is it like more how baggy items are being worn or layered. I was just looking up more about the history of hip hop fashion and I just wanted to ask some clarification questions. Also that’s fucked up “luxury” brands stole from black culture and are profiting off it when they were most likely the one’s looking down on it.
because by saying someone is “acting black” you’re insinuating that black folks are inherently different from white folks. because no one says “acting white” your implying acting differently from normal “white behavior” would equal acting black. which is kinda perpetuating the race problem here by drawing more distinction between two groups
i can see how that would suck ass. like i’m really sorry that happened to you and fuck those people right. i guess i just get defensive because i would never want someone to assume im a bigot or ignorant because of my skin color (or even gay stereotypes for that matter) the same way im sure poc don’t want stereotypes yk (stereotypes just suck)
To answer your question it’s both about the words and HOW you say it. A lot of the time people also start doing a “blaccent” which comes off a mockery. So yes you can pick up words from your friends that’s a natural thing, but please do not start changing your accent or how you pronounce the words as that can come off as mocking imo
As a Mexican of indigenous dissent I am no stranger to cultural erasure, but instead of relishing in the past admire the amount of influence that black Americans have over American culture in general. Instead of interpreting as appropriation. Who’s exactly not letting you participate?
Crown act for one LMAOO black people were discriminated against for wearing our natural hair to the point they had to make a law. People keep ignoring black voices, or getting defensive, or downplaying the lived experiences of black people to their face and all this bullshit instead of going “Damn how can I help?” Like this is literally the problem black people can’t even ASK white people to not appropriate without getting backlash what is not clicking?
Ok I’m not invalidating what you say about black peoples history. But the fact is that isn’t happening anymore. No one is ignoring black voices bffr. We’ve literally had a black man in office twice, had a black woman as a presidential candidate and vice president, Beyoncé has won more Grammies then Celine Dione Taylor swift and Elvis Presley combined, sza and Kendrick performed at the Super Bowl (Kendrick’s second time).
The reason you are facing “backlash” and not getting “help” is because you don’t need it! And what you’re “feeling” is not rooted in reality straight up. I do not see yall as victims of anybody, there are incredibly hard working black Americans who shouldn’t be held by their race.
How are u oppressed? What can we as black and brown folk not do in this country? Your feelings do not define black people as black people are not a monolith, I’ve met many of lovely black people that agree that there is nothing holding them back and they’d rather take a racist bigot then a country that is actually racist
Oh trust me no one is fuckign me over. I’d encourage you to get out of whatever mindset you are in and recognize that your skin color is not something that holds you back anymore. Racism and bigotry exist, and I hate that, but systemically I know as a first gen American I have the tools to succeed in a country that used to be not so kind to black and brown folks. Why live in the past?
…you realize that it’s possible to be racist accidentally, right? We all have gaps in our knowledge of cultures that we haven’t interacted w or learned abt. It’s all well and good if someone doesn’t consider themself racist, but saying that’s all you need to not be racist denies other people their feelings of offense and hurt at racist behavior and your own opportunity to genuinely learn abt them and their culture.
I used to make drag/ballroom (a la Paris is Burning, not the waltz) costumes and I agree. A lot of drag queens would make fun of me if I didn’t fit in (talk like them, not dress “too straight”, etc). Out of character it was mostly whatever but in character they could be vicious! I’d try not to let anything slip in the wrong place, but it happened. I’m also Asian tho, so I’m def paying for my gf to go to the best Aunties nail salon and thanking Ms Tippi
You shouldn’t use ebonics/AAVE. A lot of the people who aren’t black and use ebonics took it from black people and rebranded it as internet lingo or gen z slang or even brainrot which contributes to the problem of cultural appropriation black people face. Not to mention it’s misused and ran into the ground
Bc it kinda feels like saying “you aren’t Korean you shouldn’t be speaking Korean.” I’m not diminishing the fact that it is something taken and changed or gentrified by white people im just saying that banning the words overall from other people, aside from slurs, is something that is separating people even more from each other.
Like why would you care if, (here’s the stereotypical most brought up example), if a white woman and man wore dreads, etc? I don’t personally relate to or like anything from hip hop culture at all, as that is not what I grew up on and consider part of my soul, but isn’t the point of culture, for it to be shared?? Like what happened to the “melting pot” idea??
Because of the specific history of black people being discriminated for participating in their own culture!!!! It’s not sharing if people are shaming you for it and then turning around and doing it and calling it something else or refusing to give you credit. Also locs are VERY damaging for anybody who does not have a thick and coarse hair texture even black people with looser curls cannot get locs
I think both things can be true, that the us did not treat black folk well AND were allowed to be critical of your claims since they claim things that are based off anecdote, the black experience isn’t a monolith and I know black folk in my life who do not portray themselves like you do, I as a gay Hispanic won’t either because I can acknowledge the progress we’ve made in society, I’d rather be in the us leaguesss over Mexico because there’s a lot more here for poc
Well I agree almost across the board, but are you saying that…. we are not in a position in society to allow ourselves to be a mental pot of skin colors and cultures?? Like if we were to do so, I’d almost inherently be idling by as minority groups aren’t given the meaningful change they deserve?? If so, then yeah I agree. But you’d have to be careful that you meant lived experiences and cultural experiences, and not skin color
This is actually an interesting argument, I can see what you means. I wouldn’t say white supremacist more like western culture in general. The us admires talent but its so hard for all folk to get by these days. Eroticizing happens to all races and groups of people. Heard many people say how much they loveeee white boys. Bigger issues out there
well i mean people with straight hair shouldn’t get protective styles bc it wasn’t designed for their hair type and it’ll make it fall out. also the melting pot is kind of a myth- all the cultures in the US haven’t integrated into a cohesive one like “melting pot” implies and sharing of cultures imo requires each culture to be socially equal and since we’re still very much oppressed that is not the case
I wouldn’t say we’re oppressed. We have very present disparities but in terms of what poc and whites can do there really isn’t nothing they can’t do, given both come from decent socioeconomic status. Not to say bigotry doesn’t exist, but aye if a racist wanna scarp that’s what my second amendment is for 🤷🏽🤷🏽also I don’t think integration happens, more like everyone contributing in someway which forms broader American culture
you got it. oppression isn’t always as black and white as maybe it looks during jim crow era segregation. there’s law on paper and law in practice, and oppression has always been mostly through practice. this means oppression through social systems, widespread biases, and unconscious discrimination. plus existing systems explicitly built on racist ideals still exist so even if no one was racist the systems that haven’t changed for decades definitely are
Okay on the real: I do not want to have a conversation with you. We have conversed twice and both times I have come to the conclusion that we will simply never agree and thus conversation with be fruitless. I would recommend you research more on this subject by those better versed in this matter than me if you genuinely want to learn more
“Social” oppression whatever other guy said, 2. You didn’t answer my question, 3. Sounds like a load of bs, but this is what oppression is truly: women unable to access education in Middle East, gays being killed in certain parts of Africa, the corruption in government and police that Mexicans face, Palestinians suffering through genocide, etc etc.
ok that’s actually just incorrect oppression is just certain groups being subjected to widespread mistreatment and control. also not everything you just mentioned as examples come from explicit policy so you’re contradicting yourself. it’s not like there’s an explicit policy telling police to mistreat minorities but you still identify that as oppressive so what’s up?