I hope people remember that these are a bunch of 20 to 25 year olds who are still discovering themselves in life and none of them are fully formed individuals.
There’s literally only 2 fully developed brains on that island.
They’ll misstep and that’s ok
And it’s so clear when you look at the entire cast and how they act, then how Carl and Bryce act you can see how much more developed they are, even compared to the girls.
And that’s okay, they’re 20 to 23.