Anonymous #1 15w

nuh uh

1

Anonymous OP 15w

Yeah huh. Who is ur Top 5 just out of curiosity?

1

Anonymous #1 15w

mahomes, jackson, allen, burrow, herbert

-5

Anonymous OP 15w

“Herbert” 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

15

Anonymous #1 15w

all those laughing emojis aint making it any less true 🙂‍↔️

-2

Anonymous OP 15w

Sure let’s rank the guy who can’t even win a playoff game above a guy who just won a Super Bowl. Great logic!

3

Anonymous #1 15w

yeah exactly you get it

-3

Anonymous OP 15w

Mf said “Herbert” like if you’re gonna put someone else in the 5 spot at least make it someone sensible like Stafford or Daniels and not the guy who turns into will levis the moment he realizes he’s in a playoff game

5

Anonymous #2 15w

yeah but they’re not as good as herbert is

-2

Anonymous OP 15w

They’re better. They’d never get blown out by a team with a decimated receiving core and pitiful offense while having the best scoring defense in football

5

Anonymous #2 15w

damn didn’t know you could judge a guy who has been in the league for 5 years off of a single game

-2

Anonymous OP 15w

He’s been in the league for 5 years and still hasn’t won a playoff game. Ur not really helping ur case at all with this argument 😭

3

Anonymous #1 15w

oh yeah because he’s really had some great coaches during that time period. high caliber names like brandon staley and anthony lynn that really made their mark on the league

1

Anonymous OP 15w

Those are shitty excuses. Last I checked he still made the playoffs under Staley and proceeded to do absolutely nothing 🤯🤯

1

Anonymous #1 15w

“shitty excuses” dawg that’s his head coach? like the guy that leads the team? you familiar with the concept?

1

Anonymous #1 15w

Talent wise Herbert is better. Give Herbert the Eagles roster and watch the playoff wins come in. The only thing Hurts has on him is that he’s a better runner and can squat 600 pounds. Put on the tape you will see that Herbert is a far better passer

2

Anonymous #3 15w

“Herbert is a far better passer”. Exactly! He’s a far better passer when it comes to throwing to the other team, especially in the playoffs! But yeah Mr. Hypothetical being on the Eagles who would’ve thought

1

Anonymous #1 15w

Lol brotha you literally brought up Stafford because he “knows how to win” but he was 0-3 in the playoffs in the first 12 years of his career and Herbert is 0-2 in his first 4 years so that’s enough to exclude him am I right?

0

Anonymous #1 15w

“Someone sensible like Daniels or Stafford” so either a guy with one year in the league or a guy who didn’t win shit for over a decade until he joined a super team lol ok got it

0