I’m just going to have to disagree. I might be able meet you halfway and put him at 4 since Joe has been a no show in the playoffs, which is much higher than most people. My argument for Josh is that I watch the games and he’s simply the second best player alive. Lamar’s 2 mvps speak for themselves as well.
Well, I think Patrick Mahomes is the best QB I’ve ever seen. The only reason I’m able to elevate Jalen to 4 or 5 is him 1. Winning a ring, and 2. Him outplaying Mahomes in 1, if not 2, Super Bowls. Same thought process applies to Josh specifically, I’m not going to kill him for being borderline amazing in the playoffs every year and losing to the best player I’ve ever seen. I also had him ranked 2 last year, I cannot possibly move him lower after being named the most valuable player.