Anonymous #1 16w

All facts but idk man he might have a career yr he join the sb champs🤷🏿‍♂️😂

1

Anonymous OP 16w

Only way I’d want him is if Goedert leaves but he ain’t going anywhere and he’s better than Pitts too anyways

1

Anonymous #1 16w

Healthy Dallas is top 3 te

-2

Anonymous OP 16w

Top 5 but not 3, I’d take Kittle, LaPorta, McBride, and Hockenson over him

1

Anonymous #2 16w

You can have them over but in reality he’s top 3 when healthy ts not a debate

1

Oh shit I forgot about Bowers. Goedert isn’t even top 5 anymore, he’s 6 at best

1

Did have a drop thru thru the whole playoff run lol with 10+ rec

1

Stop talking ball

1

Anonymous OP 16w

He’s a good tight end but he’s not better than those guys

1

Anonymous #2 16w

Only thing holding Dallas back is injuries they not better than dg you expose ya ball knowledge

1

Anonymous OP 16w

Availability is an ability

1

Anonymous #2 16w

He is bro when healthy none of them fw bro the proof is in yo face

0

Anonymous OP 16w

It doesn’t matter how good you are if you’re not on the field. But even when fully healthy he’s not better than Kittle, Bowers, or LaPorta. McBride and Hockenson are debatable

1

Anonymous #2 16w

Hence y I said when healthy man I can’t argue with that

0

Anonymous OP 16w

What makes him better, those other guys have better production

1

True

1

Anonymous #2 16w

Better at catch point better blocker route running is debatable but production is the end all be all

1

Anonymous OP 16w

He’s not a better blocker than Kittle, he’s not better at the catch point than LaPorta, and Bowers runs better routes than any tight end I’ve ever seen

1

Anonymous #2 16w

What does Laporta do better than Dallas

1

Fuck no

1

Anonymous OP 16w

It’s pretty clear, Goedert is a good tight end but he’s at the top of the second tier of guys

1

Anonymous OP 16w

He is to tight ends what Baker Mayfield is to quarterbacks, very good but not the greatest

1

Anonymous #2 16w

That’s glaze not factual shit lol you’ve never watched Dallas and it shows I’ve seen Dallas make catches ik laporta cant make him and kittle is neck and neck when it comes to blocking and I’ll give you bowers but Dallas not far

1

Anonymous #2 16w

You don’t watch all of football you picking and choosing if u seen atleast 2 Philly games were dg played you’ll see it for yo own eyes

1

Anonymous OP 16w

The only tight end I’ve ever seen who’s a comparable blocker to Kittle is Gronk. Goedert isn’t a liability as a blocker but he’s not exactly an elite blocker

1

Anonymous #2 16w

Wow he isn’t a liability but he’s isn’t exactly a elite blocker you really just said that this is how Ik you don’t watch Philly ball

1

Anonymous OP 16w

He’s a damn good tight end but Kittle is probably gonna be wearing a gold jacket at the end of his career and Goedert will be like Zach Ertz a phenomenal and well respected tight end but firmly entrenched behind the elite guys from his era (Kelce and Gronk)

1

Anonymous #2 16w

You can go on yt and look at Dallas best plays from last season and you will see

1

Anonymous #2 16w

That’s glaze once again not facts

1

Exactly, I’ve always thought tiers were a more accurate way to compare guys than a numbered rank and to me the top tier of tight ends right now include Kittle, Bowers, McBride, and Hockenson and the next tier down includes guys like Goedert, Mark Andrews, Isiah Likely, Cade Otton etc

1

Isn’t putting bro over kittle he’s the only one I’m not putting over dg

1

Anonymous OP 16w

You don’t think Kittle is gonna be a Hall of Famer when he retires? Also watching highlights isn’t a good way to assess a player

1

You acting kittle being super man out there dude u gotta b a niners fan😂

0

Anonymous OP 16w

He’s clearly the best all around tight end in football and it’s not close. Bowers is probably a better receiver but there’s a huge gulf between Kittle and every other tight end, including Goedert. The other guys are all fighting for second as far as I’m concerned

1

Anonymous #2 16w

Not highlight smart guy I said top plays real time drives of him Doing elite shit and ofc I do kittle is the best te in lg rn I can’t deny that but that 2 3 spot Dallas can for sure be there lol

1

Anonymous OP 16w

And you’re showing your bias if you think it’s even a debate

1

Anonymous #2 16w

One full healthy season from dg would put all ts to bed it’s not bias you literally just uneducated when it comes dg and im educating you because ik you don’t watch him play

1

Anonymous OP 16w

He can’t until he proves he can stay healthy. Nobody makes it to the league without talent and the Eagles wouldn’t keep him around if he couldn’t play, they let Ertz walk because they liked Goedert, but that doesn’t mean he’s an elite tight end in any other context besides potential. His health and his production preclude him from being in the top 5

1

Anonymous #2 16w

Been saying that since you decided to reply to my comment lol haven’t gotta that fully healthy season from him so I don’t got a lot of room but I can go off past shit

1

Anonymous OP 16w

Let’s take Gronk as an example, he’s an undoubtedly all time great at the position but if he played his entire career fully healthy he’d hold every record a tight end could hold and he’d have them by a massive margin but because he didn’t do that because of his health there’s more of a debate about the GOAT tight end

1

Anonymous #2 16w

It’s only healthy not production that goes into health when he was healthy he overly produced when we was in the play offs last yr we went thru 3 games and he didn’t have 1 drop on 10+ rec that’s the shit they don’t show you tho because he can’t stay out long enough for it to get noticed but I will come back this post because this gone be the season

0

That’s glaze 2 u 😂😂 Philly my team and that bozo said dg not a top 3 top 5 atleast when healthy of im on ass

0

Ofc

1

Anonymous OP 16w

He’s not top 3 unless you’re looking at it through Philly colored glasses, because he’s not better than Kittle, Bowers, or McBride and he’s neck and neck with Hockenson

1

Anonymous OP 16w

Nobody’s denying he’s good, he’s just not as good as you’re saying. We all like players on our team better than anyone on some other team but that doesn’t make the evaluation objective

1

Anonymous #2 16w

Only reason u saying that dumb shit is because they can stay on the field that’s the sole reason you would even put them over bro it’s actual ball knowing lenses goofy I watch all aspects of the game with every team howany times u watched Philly ball

-1

Anonymous #2 16w

Production is the reason u put em higher that’s cool

0

Anonymous OP 16w

They were good so I watched them in prime time slots and during the playoffs. He’s good, but he’s not of that same caliber. Those other guys have the ability to take over games in a way he doesn’t really

1

Super Bowl champs fuckin bozo

0

Anonymous #2 16w

What game

0

Anonymous OP 16w

Nobody’s taking that from you, but there are only 4 Eagles who are top three at their position: Saquon, Jalen Carter, Lane Johnson, and Jordan Mailata

1

My goat?

0

U a lil ass boy on here trying to talk ball

-5

Anonymous #2 16w

Bro wtf?

-1

Anonymous #2 16w

This is the goofy shit I’m talkin about

-1

I’d take Chase, Jefferson, and CeeDee over Brown because CeeDee is the only receiver on his roster worth a damn and he still produces. I agree it’s close though

1

Anonymous #2 16w

Jus stop talking ball especially when it come to Philly ball you gotta be stop😂😂😂

0

Anonymous #2 16w

bro nobody gives a damn about them trash ass takes you saying

1

Anonymous #2 16w

Jus said cd over aj when aj missed 3+ games less receptions and still had more tds and yds per catch but yk ball tho😂😂😂

0

Anonymous OP 16w

You’re just saying my takes are trash because I’m not glazing Philly hard enough. You guys have the best roster in football but you don’t have top 3 players at every fucking position

1

Anonymous #2 16w

Never said we did and I damn right when do that’s what you supposed to when u get sick of being trash

-1

Anonymous OP 16w

He had Cooper Rush for most of the year and plays on an offense with nobody else that can play and yet he produces. Brown is a damn good receiver but his situation makes him look better than he really is

2

Had 2 back 1400 yrd seasons tho

0

Anonymous OP 16w

He’s still top 5 though

1

Anonymous #2 16w

He’s still not better than aj are u fuckin mental

0

Anonymous #2 16w

Mf think Dakota Prescott is a major step up from cooper rush

0

That’s glaze😂😂

0

Anonymous OP 16w

Cooper Rush is fucking dogshit and Dak is a top 12 quarterback

1

How many of them yrds came frm dak sorry sss stat padding cd had one good season

0

Anonymous OP 16w

He’s absolutely better than AJ, and if we revisit this in another year or two Nabers and BTJ will probably be better than him

1

Cd will never have 2 back to back 1400 yrd seasons

0

Anonymous #2 16w

They played more games???

0

Anonymous #2 16w

Stop talking ball lil bro

0

That’s great really

0

Anonymous OP 16w

I’m not saying they’re better at this minute, but the gap isn’t all that big. Those two are the rising stars at their position

1

But my gripe with Dakota is how do you have all of that and never done anything

0

He had 1 season were he had 17 and never did it again now if he did it against I’ll give it to you but if can just come into a new team and have 1 1400 yrd season then come back and do it again and once of those seasons we went to a Super Bowl

1

What’s telling is that Ik your a cowboys fan that just doesn’t wanna come terms with aj being better and he’s been better bro goes up against the best corners in the lg consistently a pure x he’s not switching to the slot and then going back

1

Anonymous OP 16w

He said he was a Chiefs fan

1

Anonymous #2 16w

Didn’t see that lol

1

Anonymous OP 16w

I’m sure you won’t dispute the NFC East is the best division for receivers in the NFL. Between Brown, Smith, McLaurin, Nabers, and CeeDee

3

Anonymous #2 16w

Something we can agree on🫱🏿‍🫲🏾

1

Of u would rather have a guy like that 😂😂

1

Rather have a guy that cooks top tier corners consistently and gets up to bowls while being in a run heavy o

1

Wow dak can throw the ball better than cooper rush that’s amazin

1

What’s his record against play offs teams tho

1

Anonymous OP 16w

Damn I really caused this whole argument didn’t I 💀

3

Anonymous #1 16w

Ngl my comment section always a war zone shit funny tho😂

1