Anonymous #6 10w

I will say, definitely one of my hotter takes, but I think Brees is a little overrated. Obviously a hall of famer and a top 10 QB ever, but I say top 10 and not top 5 for a reason. I see people all the time compare him to Rodgers when I don’t even see an argument for him being remotely close to Rodgers all time.

2

Anonymous #4 10w

I dont know that much about either quarterback to debate about this but I would like to hear your arguments for why A-Rod is better than him

1

Anonymous #6 10w

4 MVPs for ARod to 0 for Brees, on a per game basis, more TDs and less INTs, Rodgers is the all time leader in passer rating, while Brees is 7th. ARod was also a better post season performer statistically. Finally, just watching them, Brees was a very good field general to run the Sean Payton offense, but prime ARod may be the most talented QB ever. Absolutely unbelievable, only really comparable to younger Mahomes.

3

Anonymous #4 10w

I did not know that Okay, moving on to Prime GOATS (not about Brees), how would you compare Prime Rodgers to Prime MaHomes and both to Prime Brady? I am curious as to what you think because it seems like you know a lot about this

3

Anonymous #6 10w

in terms of just absolute peak play, I think Mahomes is #1, followed closely by Rodgers at #2, then Peyton Manning at #3, and Brady at #4. Brady is the GOAT, but greatness is separate from pure per game dominance, and I don’t think there’s much of an argument for Brady on a per game basis to be as good as those 3.

3

Anonymous #4 10w

Okay but what makes Peyton Manning better in absolute peak play than Tom Brady? Bro I wanna go DEEEEEEEP (pun intended) with these discussions

2

Anonymous #6 10w

2013 Manning set the all time single season passing yards record, all time single season passing TDs record, and led the highest scoring offense in NFL history lol

3

Anonymous #6 10w

and in terms of how he played, just the smartest player to ever step foot on the field. Knew exactly what was happening before the ball was snapped. He was basically an offensive coordinator in a QB’s body.

3

Anonymous #4 10w

Okay thats crazy and I know that Peyton could be a great coach if he ever decided to do that

3

Anonymous #6 10w

oh 100%. I wish he would, but it seems like he’s content with his life now

3

Anonymous #3 10w

OJ Simpson wasn’t a fucking QB

6

Anonymous #4 10w

He and Eli have that show and I feel like they are really moving it up there too 🥹 Like they are making it better for fans of Eli, Peyton, NYG, Colts, Broncos, and NFL fans in general. I hope they continue with it too

3

Anonymous #3 10w

OJ simpson got away with murder so no

0

Anonymous #6 10w

Drew Brees deserved better than the shitty defenses he got. he would’ve won super bowl 53 had that dogshit PI not happened

2

Anonymous OP 10w

Wait what had happened? Im confused

2

Anonymous #6 10w

the worst missed call in sports history. Look up Saints vs Rams missed PI

3

Anonymous #4 10w

i was sick that day and missed that call cuz i was in the bathroom

3

Anonymous OP 10w

Lucky. I watched it live and have never been more furious for a team that I didn’t care at all about lmao

2

Anonymous #4 10w

our beloved patriots played later and won tho:)

3

Anonymous OP 10w

OUR?? I’m a chiefs fan lmao

1

Anonymous succulent.testicles 10w

I lied, he technically doesn’t have every single career passing record. He doesn’t have the most interceptions.

1