No he’s not. He’s overrated as fuck. He plays like shit, has won no awards or playoff games, and in his only two playoff appearances he blew a 27 point lead and threw 4 picks and got blown out. Yet he gets all these excuses like “if he had a good offense” “if he had good receivers” etc, yet he has decent receivers and o lineman, he just sucks
Not denying that he’s folded in big games, but he definitely doesn’t suck. He’s still a really good quarterback. Just because Joel Embiid and David Pastrnak dont play well in the playoff doesn’t mean that they aren’t great players in their sport. Not saying that Herbert is on that level as an NFL quarterback, but he is still a high level player, and you are definitely underrating him