Anonymous #2 5d

Every choking QB in this era gets compared to Peyton Manning and John Elway. Those 2 are outliers. Lamar, Burrow, Allen, and Herbert don’t ALL get to be Peyton Manning. Someone has to be Phillip Rivers, Andy Dalton, or Warren Moon

0

Anonymous OP 5d

Nobody has to be anything. History isn’t going to repeat itself in the exact same way it did before. The NBA had 4 consecutive championships of Cavs/Warriors, and now there hasn’t been a repeat champion in 7 years. The distribution of super bowls in the 90s is not going to be the same as it is in the 2020s

1

Anonymous OP 5d

Now if your point is that not everyone can win a Super Bowl, that’s true. And the likelihood that Burrow, and Lamar, and Josh Allen, and Justin Herbert etc all win a Super Bowl is obviously slim. Somebody is going to be left without a chair for sure. That doesn’t mean that we can guarantee that Josh is going to be left without one

8

Anonymous #2 5d

Exactly. So expecting Josh Allen (or Lamar, Burrow, Herbert, or any other playoff choking QB) to magically appear in 4 super bowls in the back half of their careers is foolish. If anyone of them were going to win a Super Bowl, it would have happened by now

-1

Anonymous OP 5d

I agree with that except you made a big leap in logic with that last sentence

3

Anonymous #2 5d

That is my point. It’s safe to assume that not all of the “hypothetical 4” will win super bowls. If anything, only 1 of them will

0

Anonymous #3 5d

It was the best chance if you believe that the only thing keeping the Josh Allen bills from being a 2-3 time SB champion is the chiefs. But, that isn’t the case. Even if the chiefs never existed, Josh Allen and the bills would still have 0 rings, and this year proved that

1

Anonymous OP 5d

Yeah that’s basically what I’m saying. They’ve been consistently like the 3rd-5th best team in the NFL and don’t have a style that’s consistent enough to beat 3 or 4 other top teams in a row

1