NHL on Yik Yak | Why is the “best player in the NHL” discussion almost always just forwards? Not just talking about currently, have you ever heard anyone say that the best player in the NHL for any stretch of time was a defenseman?

Yik Yak

Download

Join communities on Yik Yak Download

NHL 1d

Why is the “best player in the NHL” discussion almost always just forwards? Not just talking about currently, have you ever heard anyone say that the best player in the NHL for any stretch of time was a defenseman?

Anonymous 1d

I think the only time in nhl history where a defensemen was the best player in the nhl was Bobby Orr

Anonymous

#1 1d

Yeah that’s fair, I’d argue Lidstrom was the best player for a couple years in the late dead puck era as well. I just think a lot of a defenseman’s value comes from things that are hard to statistically track and they end up getting slightly undervalued compared to other positions

Anonymous

OP 1d

I agree with you there’s no real stats to track how good a defensemen is at defending that’s why the Norris trophy is just the best offensive defensemen and so I do think really good defensive defenseman are very undervalued

Anonymous

#1 1d

Main reason I made this post was bc I realized I’d seen people argue that MacKinnon was better than McDavid but never that Makar was the best player in the NHL. Personally I still think McDavid is the best player but I’m surprised I’ve never seen anyone make that case

Anonymous

#1 1d

The defensive value of offensive defensemen ends up getting underrated too, a lot of them are still pretty solid defensively

Anonymous

OP 1d

I think mcdavid is the best player in the nhl I think maker is definitely a top 5 player in the nhl and McKinnon is the 2nd best imo so when you have two players of that caliber on one team they’re gonna be dominate