Anonymous snipsnip 16w

For these reasons, I’d say that each side’s view of God has to recognize the other two as false. (I know that I didn’t look at how Muslims and Jews view each other’s god. As I am not part of those religions, I can’t say what their perspective on the other’s theology is)

2

Anonymous snipsnip 16w

It is part of Islamic doctrine that Jews, Muslims, and Christians are all “people of the book” who worship the same God. Obviously Jews and Muslims would disagree with the Christian tributary view of God, but in Islamic doctrine at least what would be called “the father” is the same God (Judaism obviously predates Christianity so there isn’t as universal of an interpretation by the religion)

5

Anonymous #3 16w

Someone else’s view of God being false doesn’t mean they’re not worshipping the same God, it just means they’re misunderstood the reality of God, just like if someone doesn’t really get you when talking to you they’re still talking to you, even if they have misconceptions about you

4

Anonymous #1 16w

This is how my grandma is, usually she claims something along the lines of Jesus was a Jew so they can’t be that bad. But extremely islamophobic

1

Anonymous #3 16w

That’s a good point. Still, a big part of the Christian God includes Jesus in the mix. From the Christian perspective, if Jesus is not included, then there cannot be God in entirety, which mixes in falsehood with the god that is being worshipped. I would say that the analogy is more like forgetting to add someone to a call or conversation. I’m curious to know what you think about whether or not the same God is being worshipped in the analogy, or if you think that the analogy is good.

2