apple pie and pumpkin pie, no need to pit two bad bitches against each other

8

Sweet potato pie or Apple Pie

4

Caramel apple or hot apple cider

4

pecan pie 🤤🤤

3

Moths fuckin apple-cinnamon donuts

2

Thank god none of yall said candy corn 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮

1

Apple cider donuts

1

Between pumpkin pie and lattes that was a hard vote

1

Pumpkin Cheesecake (my mom makes one with a chocolate graham cracker crust)

1

Eggnog is underrated

1

Pussy

0