My only concern with this type of sentiment is the connection that many people make with the government of Israel and the people of Israel/Jewish people. If people who say “fuck Israel” can agree that *most* Jewish-Americans have nothing to do with what is going on over there, and don’t deserve mistreatment, harassment and antisemitism bc of that, then I can feel a bit better about this post.
You mean according to the Hamas “health ministry”? The same Hamas which literally built tunnels under hospitals & apartment buildings. And who bombs their own people in order to elicit sympathy from the easily confused? The same Hamas who could end this tomorrow by simply giving up the hostages?
If that was remotely close to the actual situation I would agree with you. But you realize that if Hamas, fata, PIJ, black September, the PA etc, etc, etc. had just been able to restrain themselves from trying to kill all the Jews none of that would’ve happened? If the “Palestinians” (I use quotes here because that’s kind of a made up ethnic group.) had simply stopped trying to kill all the Jews they could have had a state decades ago.
I have a question for you, if you can answer it well I will delete my comments. Why don’t the surrounding Arab states, states which the majority of the Palestinians are ethnically from by the way, not take Palestinian refugees? Israel would happily allow the civilians to leave Gaza and go to a safe place in Egypt for example. Why won’t Egypt let them? Why won’t Jordan? Lebanon? Syria? Iraq?
Because Gazan’s home is in Gaza? They aren’t obligated to leave so that you can complete your ethnic cleansing campaign. You know Israel won’t let them return and will just steal their land and settle it like with the West Bank. Not to mention how much strain taking refugees incurs on a state. They aren’t exactly well off or highly developed states and they have their own problems
Odd that they took in a lot of refugees in the past. If Gazans homes were in Gaza and they had no other qualms with them why does Egypt have an even more secure border with them than Israel did before Oct 7? Why did Jordan expelled thousands of them? Could it be that they have a habit of “resisting” just about anyone who they can, including people trying to help them? Or did the prime minister of Jordan actually secretly also oppress them? What about the whole society of Lebanon?
You are trying to paint them as inherently and intrinsically savage and unruly and resistant, not at all acknowledging the conditions they’re forced to live in under israeli occupation. You take ANY group of people and subject them to poverty, violence, occupation, trauma, racism, etc., and they will be “difficult”. Its fucking gross that you’re dehumanizing them and acting like there’s something fundamentally wrong with them as human beings. But I guess israel excels at dehumanizing don’t they
There’s nothing inherently wrong with them as human beings, plenty of them live happy and free as productive members of society… in Israel. Culturally on the other hand they are barbaric. This whole situation would be instantly solved the moment the Palestinians became willing to live in peace with Jewish people. That’s the motivation here, they want to kill all the Jews, thus they keep getting into wars with their Jewish neighbors, and because they keep losing their wars of extermination.
Hamas charter article 7: The Day of Judgment will not come about until Moslems fight Jews and kill them. Then, the Jews will hide behind rocks and trees, and the rocks and trees will cry out: 'O Moslem, there is a Jew hiding behind me, come and kill him. And that’s not new, the Arab states during the six days war were very explicit in their desire to kill all the Jews.
The yom Kippur war was the same, as have been both the intifadas. The problem is not the existence of the state of Israel, the problem is and always has been that these people hate Jews. Many leaders of the Palestinians worked directly with Nazi Germany. Many people in that region today hold positive views of hitler…. Because they hate Jews that much.
Brother, look at the tags at the top of that article. I don’t see “kill all the Palestinians” in the Israeli constitution. Not the same for Hamas, PIJ, black September etc. There are bad Israelis, there are good Palestinians. But as governments? As whole peoples? There is no comparison. And the ceaseless aggression and terrorism of successive Palestinian “governments” is what has caused these wars. If you want to see to the heart of it ask yourself this question, how do Arabs/Palestinians
That has absolutely fuck all to do with the slaughter of toddlers and babies in Gaza. That happened 2 years ago and since then your people have directly and indirectly killed upwards of hundreds of thousands of gazans, nearly half of them being women and children. We are so far beyond “an eye for an eye”. I don’t want to hear about octobter 7th because at this point it doesn’t matter and is not proportional
“Your people have directly and indirectly killed upwards of hundreds of thousands of Gazans…” Bro this is exactly what I was talking about. The Middle East stuff has nothing to do with the vast majority of Jews. This is doing of the Israeli government. Please don’t put this on us. Like, fr, the closest that I’ve been to Israel is (I shit you not) Florida. Fuck Netanyahu and his cronies. And fuck anyone that uses the conflict in the Middle East as an excuse to spew antisemitism.