
the issue is that the production/storytelling/vocals/cohesion/organization/concepts overall do not make up for the simple lyrics. the songs sound like someone told ai to write a taylor song. they aren’t particularly interesting or memorable. i love her earlier work (like the cheesy pop songs like 22 or love story or mine) but they all had other factors that made up for the less complex lyricism
i love that she’s happy and is able to make more upbeat and cheesy songs without worrying about what people think about her. but with that being said, i’m not going to pretend her newest work is good just because of that. i love taylor, but i think she had a lot of yes men in the room while creating some of these songs. and she HAS been happy and written well before, so i’m going to hold that same standard. i’m not hating on her personally, but the new stuff is just not comparable to the rest
Thank you for saying this. It’s so common for viewpoints like this to get shut down immediately or framed as being “unloyal”. This is not a cult. It’s okay to critique Taylor Swift. In fact, one would hope that criticism would make her a better song writer and music producer. Showgirl feels very rushed and not well thought through. The only song I feel is any good is Ruin the Friendship. I still haven’t listened to the newest four because of how disappointed I was with showgirl