
This question gets the whole problem completely wrong. Instead of asking what to do with rapists and felons you should be asking how to prevent them from existing in the first place, and how to turn existing ones into healthy productive members of society. Prison has consistently shown to do the exact opposite of that. Nobody is saying let criminals walk free. I'm pointing out the DOCUMENTED flaws of our current "justice" system.
Capital punishment: the National Research Council reviewed decades of studies and found no reliable evidence it deters murder. Meanwhile 200+ people sentenced to death in the US were later exonerated. You can't un-execute someone. Lashings: hurting someone doesn't touch what drove them to crime, it just adds trauma. Restitution: agreed, that's a core part of restorative justice. Funny how the one idea on your list that actually helps victims is the one that isn't about inflicting pain.
This was never about one guy, it's about how we think about crime. The DOJ's own research arm says prison is a weak deterrent, harsher punishment does little, and prison may make reoffending worse. What actually deters is the certainty of getting caught, not severity. Locking people up contains crime for a while, but nearly everyone gets out. If we want less crime, we fix the causes and actually rehabilitate instead of just warehousing people.
Whether one specific person can be rehabilitated isn't the point. Systems get built for everyone, and "public torture" has been tried for most of human history. It didn't end crime, it just made societies crueler. Even the DOJ's own research says harsher punishment does little to deter crime, and certainty of getting caught matters far more. Wanting someone to suffer is understandable. Calling it justice or crime prevention isn't accurate. It's revenge.
No, and popularity is exactly why. Lynchings were popular. The 8th Amendment bans cruel and unusual punishment specifically so a mob's mood can't decide what the state does to a person. The whole reason we hand punishment to courts instead of victims is that private revenge creates blood feuds that never end. Revenge is about how we feel, not whether there's less crime next year. And when the system gets it wrong, and it does, revenge is the part you can't take back.
Agreed, we won't stop all crime, and some people do need to be separated. My issue is treating "time" as the fix. Time is just a length, not a method. Nearly everyone we lock up comes back out, so what happens during that time decides whether they come out safer or more dangerous. Norway still has prisons, but they're built around therapy, education and jobs, and their reoffending rate is a fraction of ours. Separate people when needed, but use that time to change something.
And think about the phrase itself: "serve time." Serve it to who? The victim doesn't get healed, the community doesn't get safer, and the person doesn't get better. Sitting in a cell for X years with nothing else happening just makes someone suffer for a length we picked. That's vengeance with a calendar. We measure justice in years because it feels like payback, not because anyone ever showed 10 years fixes more than 5. If time worked, our system would have the best results on earth.
And the results speak for themselves. The US has the highest incarceration rate of any democracy on earth. If time worked, we'd be the safest developed country by a mile. Instead our violent crime looks nothing like our peers. When researchers compared US states to the rest of the world, the only countries that matched us on both incarceration AND violent crime were El Salvador, Panama, Peru and Turkey. Not Canada, not Europe. More cages, worse results.
You're right that they dodge getting caught, but ask why. That impunity isn't a quirk of a few men, it's built in. Money buys lawyers, lobbyists, delays and laws written in their favor. Treating them as a "unique case" accepts that kind of power as a given. The fix isn't a harsher cell for one guy, it's not letting that much unchecked power pile up in the first place: real transparency, funded enforcement, and accountability that doesn't bend to wealth.
It also helps to ask where our model came from. The 13th Amendment banned slavery "except as punishment for crime," and convict leasing filled that gap fast. Decolonial thinking asks us to stop treating that system as the only option. Many Indigenous justice traditions focus on repairing harm and restoring the community, not caging people. The Navajo Nation still runs a Peacemaking program today. Other models exist. We were taught not to look at them.
You're not gonna like my answer. Radical empathy, for everyone, including them. That doesn't mean letting them off. It means we strip the power, not the humanity. Take away what lets them harm people: the wealth, the positions, the protection. Make them repair what they broke. Then ask honestly what produced them, because a culture that makes monsters will keep making them. Cruelty toward them just teaches the next generation that power and domination are the point.
dont worry i know i do sociology and environmental justice. it’s just the details of fundamentally changing a society (which takes time) while still holding those who are powerful and do horrible things accountable (without reinforcing the fucked up carceral system we have) are hard
and who? the people trump is hurting shouldn’t be required to meet him with radical empathy when he has no empathy for them. if he was stripped of power and placed within a system of justice with professionals who can facilitate that i’d be all for it. but right now that doesn’t exist, and most likely it won’t ever exist in trump’s lifetime
The practical problem is that you're picturing him at the top, single-handedly causing all this harm. That's an illusion. He's an 80-year-old man surrounded by staff, donors and a party that profit from keeping him in front of the cameras. Honestly, there's an elder abuse angle to it. Thousands of people write the policies, sign the orders and carry them out. Remove him and that machine keeps running with a new face. Fix the machine, not just the mascot.
And this is where spheres of control matter. None of us controls what happens to Trump. Obsessing over punishing one man we'll never touch just burns our energy. What we do control: how we treat people, what our local DA and jail policies look like, who we vote for in city races, what we teach kids about power and harm. That's where a culture actually changes. The practical answer isn't "what do we do with him," it's "what do we do with everything within reach."
Accountability looks like personal integrity. When you witness harm in your everyday life, you refuse to go along with it. You can't control him, but you can control yourself. And that's not a small thing, because no powerful person acts alone. Every abuse of power needs clerks, cops, staffers and neighbors who look away. When enough people stop cooperating, power has nothing to stand on. That's the accountability that actually works, and it starts with us.
I disagree. The feeling is valid because nobody chooses their anger, but acting on it is a different thing, and that mentality is the root of our cultural harm. "He hurt people, so he deserves to suffer" is the exact logic that built the system we're both criticizing. It's also his logic. If we keep it and just aim it at him, nothing changes except who's on the receiving end. Wanting him punished is human. Building our response around that want is how the cycle repeats.
DOJ's National Institute of Justice, "Five Things About Deterrence": nij.ojp.gov/topics/articles/five-things-about-deterrence. It says the certainty of being caught is a vastly more powerful deterrent than the punishment, and that prisons themselves may be schools for learning to commit crimes.
You automatically act like you assume everyone who disagrees with you slightly is pro-Prison Industrial Complex. It’s kinda sad all things considered, especially cause you rant and whine about assuming beliefs all the time. Private prisons are bad. Overpopulated prisons are bad. Slave labor in prisons are bad. The biggest prison in my home state literally has a rodeo for prisoners. They treat it like a zoo attraction. It’s barbaric.
Yes, my worldview is love, and I'll own that. But love isn't softness. It's a practice and a choice, and it's harder than hate. Love doesn't mean letting anyone off the hook. It means holding people accountable without becoming what we're fighting. Hatred is what built this system, and more hatred won't dismantle it. You can mock that if you want. I'm not going to let anyone talk me into hating people as a solution.
Good faith means you assume the other person means what they say and respond to their strongest version, not intentionally choosing your worst guess. It's the same principle as presumption of innocence: you don't convict someone on a label you already decided fits. Ever since you ran out of arguments against you’ve done the exact opposite. Every time you can't refute what I actually said, you stamp a new label on me and treat it as proven. That isn't an argument. It's a verdict without a trial.
"allergic to making a good point" proves it. I posted DOJ research, recidivism data, Nuremberg, Popper, and an actual alternative. You didn't refute any of it. You just declared none of it counts. That's the whole pattern: decide the verdict first, then dismiss anything that doesn't fit. If my points were bad, you'd quote one and take it apart. You haven't done that once, because insults are easier than answers.
I made a good faith assumption that’s what you meant considering of the few times I’ve interacted with you, 3/5 have been you whining about how bad it is to say you want Trump in prison. When majority of the interactions we have had have been spurred because of that, it starts to look like someone doesn’t want Trump in prison
That's not good faith, that's building a case. Counting my comments to decide what I "really" think, while ignoring what I actually say, is a witch hunt. So here it is plainly: I want Trump held accountable. What I'm against is using him as an excuse for everyone else to dodge accountability. Like right now: you'd rather prosecute my motives than take responsibility for misrepresenting me. That's the exact pattern I'm criticizing.
Accountability means he faces due process for every crime he's charged with, like anyone else. If convicted, he's held securely so he can't keep doing harm. He pays restitution to the people he hurt. He loses the wealth and positions he used as weapons. And the people who enabled him face consequences too. What I reject is pretending one sentence for one man fixes anything, while the machine that made him keeps running.
Rehabilitation here isn't about being nice to offenders. It's about protecting the next kid. Most people convicted of these crimes eventually get released. In Canada, a program called Circles of Support and Accountability cut sexual reoffending by 83% compared to matched offenders without it. If something prevents future child abuse and you reject it because it feels too "loving," you're choosing your anger over children's safety.
AGAIN, prison abolition doesn't mean abolishing the idea of keeping dangerous people from hurting others. It means replacing a system built on punishment with one built on prevention, repair and actual rehabilitation. If "reform" is the word you prefer, fine. We want the same things. But stop taking the worst-case reading of everything I say and then telling me what I believe. I care whether you're engaging respectfully and in good faith.
That's not a gotcha, and no such guarantee exists. If you mean execution, the US has exonerated 200+ people from death row, so your "guarantee" kills innocent people too. I've already said how this works: if someone won't change, they don't get to leave. They stay restricted because of their own choices. My love is exactly why I'm adamant about that. Protecting children and rehabilitation aren't opposites. That's the whole point of it.
"Fake progressive" was a label, and I've spent all day criticizing labels in place of arguments, so I'll own that. But my actual point stands though: cheering for one man in a cage feels like justice while changing nothing, and that impulse is the same one that built the system we all say we oppose. I'm not trying to invalidate anyone. I'm asking people to aim higher than catharsis.
And what if pigs fly? It’s not possible. Prove to me how passive containment reduces crime more than containment with active rehabilitation coupled with prevention in our culture conventions. Oh wait you can’t because it doesn’t. Now address my fucking point instead of asserting your opinion as fact. Killing every offending pedophile does absolutely nothing to actually end pedophilia is our culture. A culture that creates monsters will keep creating them. Locking them up after the fact is lazy.
“personally in your ideal world” is the wrong framing. The only thing that will change anything is collective action. We all need to collectively be rescinding his power over us. Why do you think I’m speaking up?? Power doesn’t come from people who just have it, it comes from us giving them power over us. If enough people stop going along with the bullshit, it loses its power and suddenly you can question any idea. Accountability first requires that he no longer has the power to avoid it.
No you didn’t. You asked an unanswerable question. Locking him up is a valid demand. It just doesn’t prevent systemic inequality, child abuse, civil unrest, or the climate crisis. It’s cathartic, but not much else. And even then, it’s on you to provide a step by step plan of how you are going to get him behind behind bars and keep him there. The burden of proof is yours.