
It’s my fault for vagueposting Marxist concepts. This is in reference to the Dictatorship of the Proletariat. A government under capitalism will be an instrument for the bourgeoisie to subjugate the proletariat or an instrument for the proletariat to subjugate the bourgeoisie; these are the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie and the dictatorship of the proletariat, respectively. This is what i referenced in the post
Yeah, I actually think this is impossible. The only way socialism is possible is with democracy. If you put a group of people in charge of distributing resources, no matter how virtuous they are, in time they will always distribute the resources to themselves. Democracy makes it possible to change leaders and thus remove groups distributing power unfairly to themselves. The state exists as a defensive social technology against other states. It’s not going away even under social democracy.
“Dictatorship of the proletariat” is still a dictatorship. All “proletarian dictatorships” in history have devolved into absolutist Monarchy (literally, “rule by one”), and turned socialism into a kind of religious canon to justify the power of elites rather than a practical system.
You are arguing with me about the form of the government rather than its content. It is clear that you have never read and don’t know what I’m talking about: you are just not a fan of the word “dictatorship”. If you continue along this line of thought, you will be nothing more than a social democrat and you will make no fundamental change
I am a social democrat. I think communism is impossible, but non-marxist socialism (as they have in Europe) is achievable and beneficial. The state will not wither away, because the state does not exist for the reasons you think it exists. The primary purpose of the state - as it developed out of medieval warlordism - is to defend the people who sustain the state. It will not go away until people no longer need to be defended from states.
The state will manufacture situations in which it is necessary to sustain its power, even unto creating wars where there were none before. The state must be constrained by democracy and by a firm public dedication to human rights, but it must hold itself in readiness to protect from outside attack and help mediate justice.
You are delusional. “Non marxist socialism as they have in europe” relies on extraction from the global south. This extraction itself is inhumane, but it is also unsustainable. When inevitable financial collapse comes (and it always comes), the tools that the North uses to extract from the South will be used against its own population. For example, the counter-insurgency technology and tactics used in Vietnam were later used against Americans…
…For a more modern example, the military & the NYPD train with the IDF; the IDF’s tactics are thus used against us. This is the Imperial Boomerang, discussed in Cesaire’s Discourse on Colonialism. To be a social democrat, you must presuppose the existence of the Empire. You don’t want change, you just want more of the fruits of people’s exploitation abroad
If you truly want socialism, you must read the literature so you don’t have these misunderstandings. Under social democracy, the social relations which produce our exploitation will continue. If you ignore this and continue your ways, just call yourself a democrat. Calling your views “socialism” does more harm than good