Yik Yak icon
Join communities on Yik Yak Download

___joker__

And socialism isn’t a reflection of how its constant tried time and time again, right?

cia.gov

Except liberalism nowadays is not a reflection of its revolutionary roots now is it? Its goal is to uphold the status quo.
upvote -6 downvote

default user profile icon
Anonymous 15h

Socialism has lifted 800 million people out of poverty (low estimate), raised literacy across the board, fought off the largest land invasion in history, achieved higher life expectancy than the US while under the longest blockade in history, and so on. Recognizing the flaws of capitalism and addressing them, even if imperfectly, is far more effective than just saying “b-but it’s scary…” and then allowing the status quo to continue

upvote 8 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous 15h

1. Yall should kiss 2. When has socialism been tried without being undermined in multiple crucial ways?

upvote 4 downvote
🃏
Anonymous replying to -> #2 15h

Effective is when we cherry pick now?

upvote -3 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #2 15h

this is mr status quo saying "allowing the status quo to continue" gets him off

upvote 8 downvote
🃏
Anonymous replying to -> #3 15h

Go start your revolution against the status quo, bro. Not looking you’re doing a whole lot from your dorm.

upvote -5 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> ___joker__ 15h

I’m not gonna pretend socialist governments are without failure. I am only going to say that, given the context of their situations—given that they stare down the barrel of the most powerful global empire in history—Socialism has more than proved itself. Given the inequality, the genocide, the homelessness, and the hunger that Capitalism produces and reproduces, it is clear to me that Socialism is the path forward

upvote 4 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #2 14h

Do you have any sources for your claims here? Not because I think you’re wrong but because I’d like to read more about it and it’s always good to have a source

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 14h

If your political system is undermined every time you try to institute it, it probably sucks.

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 14h

Oh that’s how it works? I would expect you to say then that the abolitionist movement in the us sucked too then right? Because of how many people tried to undermine it?

upvote 0 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 13h

Pretty sure the abolitionist movement succeeded, unlike your shitty collectivist nonsense. Good try.

upvote 0 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 13h

You didn’t say anything about ultimate success, you said that if a system is undermined every time you try to institute it it probably sucks. I understand wanting to walk away from that though given how clearly absurd it is in the context of slavery or women’s suffrage or any other popular movement that was undermined by powerful Americans

upvote 0 downvote
🃏
Anonymous replying to -> #4 13h

Hooooly ball knowledge. Collectivists trying to claim the abolitionist movement is always funny asf.

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 13h

Obviously the implication was that it was successfully undermined. You’re not very bright.

upvote 2 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 13h

I’m sure that was the implication lol, always a caveat when the statement doesn’t stand on its own. Have you thought about who was undermining socialism all over the globe and what their motives might be? You think that the cia just deeply cares about the wellbeing of Guatemalans and assassinated their socialists for the wellbeing of regular Guatemalans? Because socialism just sucks? Sounds plausible

upvote 0 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> ___joker__ 13h

What do you want to claim it was the capitalist class who wanted slavery to end? You think the northern elite gave af about ending slavery? Do you think Abe Lincoln did?

upvote 0 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 13h

You literally brought up socialism being undermined in response to someone saying that it’s never succeeded. Of course that was the implication. Did you forget the entire thread already?

upvote 0 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 13h

Some of them did. Morality aside, slavery is an inferior economic system. It’s much easier to sustain economic growth when the laboring class has money and can actually buy the commodities they’re producing. In a way, mass production created the conditions for ending slavery, since the lower classes could now purchase cheap consumer goods.

upvote 0 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 13h

Brother don’t get mad at me because your point wasn’t clear. I don’t suppose you’re able to answer my question about motives? I understand if so

upvote 0 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 13h

Slavery also hinders productivity by slowing technological innovation, since higher quality technology for production was often not used in slave labor because the slaves would damage it.

upvote 0 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 13h

It’s not my fault that you have a tiny goldfish brain and keep forgetting your own points.

upvote 1 downvote
🃏
Anonymous replying to -> #1 13h

No 🤣 I'm not saying capitalists ended slavery. I'm saying class analysis can't explain it. Slavery was a racial caste system, and plenty of Northern capitalists were fine with it because cotton paid their bills. Abolition was pushed by Black abolitionists like Douglass, by religious reformers, and by enslaved people resisting. Race was the point, not a side effect of class.

upvote 5 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> ___joker__ 13h

His argument is literally “capitalists didn’t single-handedly abolish slavery, therefore we need communism” lmfao

upvote 0 downvote
🃏
Anonymous replying to -> #4 13h

Communists are actually some of the worst people unironically. I’ve been on my Spanish Civil War kick so I’ve been reading a lot about it. They actually lost that fucking civil war because communists knifed every single left aligned group in the back rather than trying to fight the Francoists as one cohesive front. Kind of sounds like something similar we’re dealing with today!

upvote 5 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> ___joker__ 13h

Have you read beevor’s book on the Spanish civil war? Highly recommend.

upvote 1 downvote
🃏
Anonymous replying to -> #4 13h

I have not. Will look that up

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> ___joker__ 12h

He talks a lot about leftist infighting and how it crippled the war effort, the ussr stealing Spain’s gold reserves, attacking other leftist groups for being “Trotskyist,” refusing to arm anarchists, etc

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 12h

If you ever manage to think up an answer about my question on us motives for violently undermining socialism everywhere it was tried lmk! Kinda hard to understand the dynamics here if that isn’t understood

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> ___joker__ 12h

I never claimed communists ended slavery, I’m saying that it was only established and perpetuated so long and in such a cruel way because of the ways capitalist systems work. We wouldn’t have had that problem in the first place if not for the capitalist leaders who prioritized profit over everything else

upvote 0 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 12h

And now we have capitalism without slavery, so what are you bitching about?

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 12h

Also give me a break lmao, I’m ‘oversimplifying’ things because you can’t thoroughly read my comments meanwhile you’re over here with the “communists bad cause infighting” like every political faction doesn’t suffer from infighting.

upvote 0 downvote
🃏
Anonymous replying to -> #4 12h

100% going to say the global south and South Pacific is modern day slavery. You already know this guy is going to say this lol

upvote 2 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 12h

1. Still waiting on that rather important answer to the question above 2. You don’t think we have slavery anymore? What makes you think that?

upvote 0 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> ___joker__ 12h

It’s literally legally allowed under the us constitution, surely you know this. And that’s just explicit slavery, not more nuanced types of quasi slavery like medical debt slavery

upvote 0 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 12h

You’re asking why the US opposed communist regimes in other countries? Obviously it’s because they were a threat to our geopolitical interests. Is that a question that needs to be asked?

upvote 1 downvote
🃏
Anonymous replying to -> #4 12h

>inb4 called nationalist imperialist

upvote 3 downvote
🃏
Anonymous replying to -> #1 12h

Capitalism made the cotton trade bigger and more brutal, sure. But slavery existed in Rome, Egypt, the Islamic world, West African kingdoms, and the Aztec empire, thousands of years before anyone was talking about capital. People enslaving people is about power, not one economic system. You don't get to lay that at capitalism's feet.

upvote 4 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 11h

Guatemalans wanting to try a socialist system in their own country is a threat to the us? So much so that we needed to kill scores of their civilians? But don’t we believe in the right to self determination? Do you think the Guatemalan socialists posed a threat to the safety of Americans? I’d love it if you could elaborate on that

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> ___joker__ 11h

Why do you think Frederic Douglass was so intentional about highlighting the unique cruelty of the American system of slavery? One explicitly driven by American capitalism? “Go where you may, search where you will, risk through all the monarchies and despotisms of the old world, travel through South America, search out every abuse and when you have found the last, lay your facts by the side of everyday practices of this nation, and you will say with me that, for revolting barbarity and shameless

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 11h

-hypocrisy, America reigns without rival.” July 4 1852

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 10h

*roam through all the monarchies

upvote 1 downvote
🃏
Anonymous replying to -> #1 10h

I’m sorry, what was Douglass’ most delivered lecture again?

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> ___joker__ 10h

You’re gonna have to enlighten me, I’m not a Douglass expert

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 9h

Yes, states geographically close to our own embracing a political system that aligns them with a bloc hostile to us is a threat.

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 9h

You mean in the prison system? I don’t see any problem with that.

upvote 1 downvote
🃏
Anonymous replying to -> #1 9h

Self Made Man. You should read it.

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 9h

Why not? You don’t think powerful private prison companies lobbying for harsher sentences to deliver them more slave labor is problematic?

upvote 0 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 9h

Can you elaborate? What possible harms could come out of a socialist Guatemala with which we share no borders? And who the soviets explicitly said they had no interest in partnering with?

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 9h
post
upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 9h

Do you condemn Soviet support for communists in Vietnam?

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 9h

I’m gonna be so fr I cannot read that, could you resend it larger somehow?

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 9h

https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w25715/revisions/w25715.rev0.pdf

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 9h

I’ll answer your question but would you mind responding to mine first?

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 8h

Communists support the global overthrow of capitalism and believe in inciting revolution abroad, so obviously it’s in the interests of capitalist nations to suppress communist movements.

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 8h

Sorry can’t follow links here either

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 8h

It’s a study that concluded that the association between private prisons and longer sentencing (23 days on average, also no association with a difference in WHETHER one was found guilty or not) is due to judges internalizing cost differences (private prisons are cheaper) rather than the association being caused by the direct influence of private prisons.

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 8h

Can you lmk who conducted the study and where it was published? Or the name?

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 8h

Screenshot the link and you can copy and paste it into your browser and read the whole thing

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 8h

Also why didn’t you respond to my other comments about how the economic progress attained under capitalism made slavery an obsolete form of production?

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 8h

Idk I think you have to appreciate the irony of this comment. Both capitalists and communists want to spread their ideologies globally but it was the capitalist who did it most famously and aggressively. Why did we take Hawaii or the Philippines? Or brute force our way into china or Japan for trade? We’ve forced capitalism on the majority of the world and ironically enough are the people actually inciting revolutions and coups abroad, for the purpose of killing fledgling socialist movements

upvote 0 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 8h

What’s ironic about it? You asked me why the US opposes communist movements and I told you.

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 8h

I mean it’s projection at its finest yk? Guatemala was a threat because we “thought” the soviets were behind it even though we knew they weren’t? And we had to step in and orchestrate a coup in that country because we thought they might be up to something?

upvote 0 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 8h

Cause yeah I mean it’s in our interests to rob and lie and cheat but does that mean it’s ok? Should we be ok with the cia facilitating the execution of millions of supposed communist civilians just because we thought it might strengthen our hand?

upvote 0 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 8h

It’s in America’s interest to suppress communism abroad regardless of Soviet involvement. How am I projecting? Lmao

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 8h

You didn’t ask me if it was okay, you asked me why America supports counterrevolution abroad.

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 8h

I didn’t mean to say you were projecting, I more meant that the American propaganda talking points are all projection, not you personally. And fair, you answered what I asked. I guess what I’m pushing back against is this idea that communism presented a threat to America, when in reality successful socialist/comminist countries are only really dangerous to America in the same way that successful slave revolutions are dangerous to slaveholders. Does that seem fair?

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 8h

Like if we can agree that America is just an empire who preaches about freedom and self determination but really just brutally crushes competition like any other empire then I think we agree

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 8h

No, because I don’t accept the premise that communism is morally superior to capitalism, which is obviously what you’re implying with the slavery bit.

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 8h

Nearly any state powerful enough to interfere in the affairs of other states does so. The Soviets did it in Afghanistan, Africa, Eastern Europe, Spain, Vietnam, and even came close to nuking a communist neighbor over a border dispute. This is just a geopolitical reality.

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 8h

I mean I guess that’s the disagreement then, I think it’s pretty clear that the capitalist countries did far more meddling in other countries affairs than the Soviet’s did. The communists might’ve overseen some terrible civilian deaths in their own countries but they didn’t orchestrate mass killings in the name of communism like the us did in the name of capitalism

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 8h

And again I’m not saying communism is perfect by any means, but I do think it’s quite obvious that the cruelest form of slavery being built in America has a lot to do with the motives established under capitalism

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 7h

America just had more global influence than the Soviets. Did small and weak capitalist countries kill more people abroad than the USSR?

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 7h

Why are all of your pro-communist arguments based on American slavery? Pre-capitalist societies had slaves too.

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 7h

I’m not sure that’s a really fair comparison. Essentially zero small and weak countries has any strong foreign ideological policy to speak of and essentially all of the largest and most powerful countries have tried to influence events in foreign countries. The difference is that the largest communist nations largely did that in border nations while the capitalist ones went global with their campaigns of undermining the will of foreign populations who chose socialist leaders only to have them

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 7h

Slimed out by the cia

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 7h

Idk it was just the topic at hand, ig I said this to joker not you but American slavery was uniquely cruel and unlike all other forms of slavery and I think that has to do mainly with the profit motives that exist under capitalism

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 6h

That’s exactly my point. Projecting power isn’t exclusive to a particular ideology, it’s about whether a state has the means to do so. And since when does Spain border Russia?

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 5h

I said largely, the soviets tended to mostly exert influence on countries in their backyard. Which is the difference, they had the ability to become involved with socialist movements in, say, Indonesia, but didn’t. The us had the power and did exert influence, which is why 1 million of their civilians were killed for being alleged communists. There aren’t really any comparable atrocities committed under the name of communism in foreign countries

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 5h

I just listed plenty of countries whose affairs the Soviets involved themselves in that didn’t border Russia, though I don’t really see how that’s relevant anyway.

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 5h

Again I’m not saying it has to be border country, just that they tended to focus on countries close to them as opposed to all over the globe. And point being that they didn’t interfere as widely or with as much disregard for the lives of civilians as the us did.

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 5h

But it is a thing that’s hard to quantify I’ll give you that. Just seems intuitively true that if the Soviets ever had a project to match the cia anti communist shenanigans in terms of scope and cruelty that we would’ve heard about it, the us government are the first people to parade evidence of evil communist activity when they find it. Which is why I have the idea that I’m correct in my analysis despite not having great solid numbers to point to

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 4h

Assuming that you’re correct, what’s the implication? It’s probably true that the US has exerted a higher degree of influence in the affairs of other states, but what point are you trying to make by bringing that up?

upvote 1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #4 4h

That capitalist systems result in more inhumane treatments of people living in capitalist countries (my point about American slavery, modern wealth inequality…etc) and that they export more terror around the world in the name of endless profit seeking. I think the number of peaceful countries terrorized by the us during the Cold War sorta backs that up

upvote 1 downvote