
considering someone with a different political opinion than you subhuman is a crazy take. I understand having an issue with radical ideology, but generalizing an entire group is odd. Like hardcore maga people yeah they suck, but not every single republican is evil -coming from a democratic
Research shows that fascism is not just a worldview. It’s a sociocultural disease that impacts people even of sound mind (hence you using the term “subhuman” which is an inherently fascist term). Fascism isn’t congenial, it’s contracted. And you contracted it when you decided “subhuman” is a justified moral classifier.
Nice clarification lol. But notice you went from "open borders" to "not deporting illegal immigrants." Those aren't the same position, and nobody here argued either one. That's what I meant by strawman: arguing against a version of the other side nobody in the conversation said. And "I hate people who come here illegally" is the same energy as "Republicans = subhuman." Disagree with the policy all you want, but that's where the dehumanizing starts.
It's not literally a felony. Overstaying a visa, which is a huge share of undocumented people, isn't a crime at all. It's a civil violation, like a traffic ticket. Crossing without inspection is a misdemeanor the first time; it's only a felony if someone re-enters after deportation. If breaking a rule means you lose all respect as a person, most of us would qualify. Strict borders is a policy view. "I hate them" is something else.
Then you know Jesus was a refugee. His family fled to Egypt because Herod was killing children (Matt 2:13-15). "Dangerous conditions" was exactly their reason. Lev 19:34: "The stranger that dwelleth with you shall be unto you as one born among you, and thou shalt love him as thyself." Matt 25:35: "I was a stranger, and ye took me in." Hard to square that with "I hate them."
Nehemiah built a wall to defend a ruined city from enemy armies (Neh 4), not to keep out people fleeing danger. Nehemiah was an exile himself, serving a foreign king. And in Neh 8 the people read the whole Law aloud, the same Law that says "the stranger that dwelleth with you shall be unto you as one born among you." The wall didn't cancel that. Zechariah, same era: "oppress not the widow, nor the fatherless, the stranger, nor the poor" (7:10).
We don't even need New Testament precedence here. Lev 19:34 is Old Testament, and Jesus said he came to fulfill the law, not abolish it (Matt 5:17). Both testaments say the same thing about strangers. Also, if we're quoting scripture, Matt 5:22 has some words about calling your brother names. "Rightoid" isn't helping.
Both of you, step back. Most people can't "enter legally" because there's no line: green cards are capped per country, and some Mexican family visa backlogs run 20+ years. Immigrants are incarcerated at lower rates than native-born citizens, and most convicted fentanyl traffickers are US citizens. Meanwhile employers profit off workers who can't report wage theft or abuse, and that weakens bargaining power for everyone. We're fighting each other while they cash in.
I think that everyone should have to go through a screening process that is deep and thorough and if they can pass they can enter legally. I don’t understand why that’s an issue 😭. My family has been personally hurt by illegal immigrants taking jobs away from us and killing one my family members. I want my country to be secure and safe from criminals and their connections.
I'm really sorry about your family. That's real, and nothing I've said is meant to wave it away. But the cartels that did that are a tiny fraction of people crossing, and they prey on migrants too: extortion, kidnapping, trafficking. Many people coming are fleeing those same groups. Thorough screening is something we can agree on. Where we differ is whether everyone else should be treated like the people they're running from.
I think for something like this you have to air the side of caution and look at everyone with a certain prejudice until they have been screened because that’s how we let terrorists and others that want to harm Americans in. Also the stricter the border the less money these coyotes for the cartel and gangs make. If we have a stronger border we find these guys and we lock them up.
Two things. Stricter borders actually make smugglers richer: as enforcement tightened, coyote fees went from a few hundred dollars to thousands, which is how cartels took over smuggling. And MS-13 started in LA among Salvadorans who fled a civil war the US helped fund, then spread back to Central America through US deportations. Prejudice-first policy helped create it. And Heb 13:2: some have entertained angels unawares.
No there’s is a precipice where you have such a strong border you find all of the coyotes and smugglers and you ruin their numbers. Ms-13 happened because we didn’t have a stronger border and because we didn’t take over Central America like we should’ve. We never should’ve stopped manifest destiny.
You told us you're Mexican. Manifest destiny is the doctrine the US used to take half of Mexico in 1848. Even then, many Americans opposed taking all of it because they didn't want Mexicans as citizens; Sen. Calhoun said ours is a government of the white race. And the US did "take over" Central America, repeatedly: the Banana Wars, the 1954 Guatemala coup, funding El Salvador's civil war. That's where MS-13's story starts. More conquest is how we got here.
Manifest destiny wasn't just expansion. It was ethnic cleansing. The Indian Removal Act forced tribes off their land; thousands of Cherokee died on the Trail of Tears. In California, the Native population fell from about 150,000 to 30,000 in 25 years, and its first governor openly called for a "war of extermination." The state formally apologized in 2019 and called it genocide. Calling that God's will is taking the Lord's name in vain (Ex 20:7).
That's "might makes right," and it's the cartels' exact philosophy: take what you can hold by force. You can't condemn them and cheer for it. And there's no such thing as "absolute control": the US couldn't hold Vietnam or Afghanistan, and occupation breeds the resistance it's trying to crush. It wasn't a fair tech contest either; epidemics devastated Native nations first, then treaties got broken. Matt 5:5: the meek inherit the earth. Not the strong. The meek.
War is always been fought and is going to be fought. The Indians themselves killed one another to appease Europeans. Vietnam and Afghanistan aren’t connected to the US by land. The US should own from Canada to chile. The resources and land these countries have will be better served working for the states than for them.
Notice how I called out this hate, and instead of repenting, you dug in to justify it. Now you're justifying war and conquest from Canada to Chile, which includes Mexico, the country your family came from. Galatians 5:14: "For all the law is fulfilled in one word, even in this; Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself." Not conquer. Love.
Love doesn't take someone's land and resources for yourself. You said their resources would be "better served working for the states than for them." That's not love, that's ownership. 1 Cor 13:5: love "seeketh not her own." I love them too, which is why I don't want them ruled by a system with our track record: removal, the Guatemala coup, deporting people back into danger. Love asks people what they want. It doesn't decide for them.
Venezuelans celebrated a dictator being removed. That's not the same as wanting to become US territory. And the US didn't take Venezuela over: Maduro's own vice president took power, and dozens died in the strikes. People flee here to escape violence and collapse, not because they're asking to be annexed. Celebrating a tyrant's fall and wanting a new ruler from Washington are very different things.
Notice the pattern: every time control fails, your answer is more control. A stronger border, then conquering Central America, then Canada to Chile. Control breeds resistance, resistance gets met with violence, and then the violence needs justifying, which is where you've ended up. The cartels rule exactly this way. Jesus rejected it: rulers of the Gentiles exercise lordship over them, "but so shall it not be among you" (Mark 10:42-43).
You just made my point. A "puppet" government and "our oil companies on their oil" is control without consent, with their resources going to us. That's exactly what I said love doesn't do. And "statehood if they please" doesn't fit with "the US should own Canada to Chile." Either they get to choose or we own them. You can't have both. And if they get to choose, they can also choose no.
I believe in Christ. And I believe the United States is christs nation. You want to let people in to flee these horrible places but we have the power to make them better places. But people like you want to be saints and let these ppl in instead of addressing the issue with “violence” because you’d rather just forget abt the blood than see it on your own hands
They can be a state or a territory but they should be under the United States moniker because we will provide protection and improve these “horrible conditions” they are fleeing. I don’t understand how I’m supposed to feel bad that their country sucks so much they want to come to mine. But my country can make their country better but that’s bad.
Jesus said "my kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight" (John 18:36). No nation is Christ's nation. When Peter drew a sword to defend Jesus himself, Jesus told him to put it away: "all they that take the sword shall perish with the sword" (Matt 26:52). And I'm not avoiding the blood. It's already on our hands: removal, coups, wars. Christ shed his own blood. He never asked us to shed anyone else's.
I want the land and everyone living on it to heal, all of it. Healing doesn't come from the sword. And "we'll make their countries better" gets it backwards: the is US what helped make them worse. Coups, funded wars, our drug demand, and US guns: most guns traced from Mexican crime scenes came from here. Stop arming, stop extracting, help repair what we broke. Isaiah 2:4: beat swords into plowshares. Rev 22:2: the leaves of the tree were for the healing of the nations.
Straight answer: honor the treaties the US already signed with Native nations and return land through Land Back. Stop arming militaries and backing coups in Latin America. Crack down on US guns flowing south. Treat addiction here as a health issue so cartels lose their market. Expand legal pathways and asylum processing so people don't need coyotes. Invest in the countries we destabilized instead of extracting from them. None of that requires a sword.
That’s impossible I said not lala land. Generations of people have built families on that land they also already have reserves. Addiction is treated here but only for those that want it you said early you can’t force people to do something so the same is still true. Asylum seekers do not need expansion they need to follow the letter of the law. We invest billions into every country it’s called the UN that we are the largest funded and backer.
Funny that conquering everything from Canada to Chile is realistic but honoring signed treaties is lala land. Land Back doesn't mean evicting families. Much of it involves public land: the National Bison Range was returned to the Salish and Kootenai tribes in 2020. And seeking asylum IS following the law; US law lets anyone here apply, however they arrived. On addiction, most people who need treatment never get it. It's access, not force.
You can check yourself into a mental hospital anytime you want. We have more military power than any other nation in the history of the world ofc taking land is realistic. But again we won that land in war where many lost their lives to earn it taking it away now is pointless. Again it’s just sucking the dick of Indians. Seeking asylum is following the law yes but we do not need to let in every asylum seekers
"Check yourself in anytime" isn't how it works. Psychiatric beds are so scarce that people wait days in ERs for one, uninsured patients get crushing bills, and voluntary admission still requires an open bed and meeting criteria. Meanwhile the biggest mental health providers in the country are jails: LA County, Cook County, Rikers. We don't treat people, we lock them up. You’re the one in lala land. It’s that you chose to deflect that at me.
And since you brought up the UN: its human rights bodies have repeatedly criticized the US for mass incarceration, solitary confinement, the death penalty, surveillance, and poverty. A UN rapporteur toured the US in 2017 and found tens of millions in poverty and the poor being criminalized for it. We fund the UN and then ignore what it says about us. Also, "sucking the dick of Indians"? You're talking about the people whose land it was.
And notice what happens when you run out of answers: "lala land," "know everything," "perfect morals," "sucking the dick of Indians." None of that is an argument. Still unanswered: Jesus telling Peter to put away the sword. US guns arming the cartels. Asylum being the law. Your own words, "puppet" and "our oil companies on their oil." Answer any one of those and we can keep talking. Insults aren't a rebuttal.
Crazy people belong in jail. They do not belong in the general population. There are people who are incurable because they do not wish to be cured. The UN is a bunch of cry babies that should listen to whatever we say. I dislike the death penalty bc it is too easy on ppl that deserve jail time. They LOST the war. Do you want to give the Germans back all the land they lost in the war? That’s the same idea.
Two comments ago the UN was proof we invest in other countries. Now it's crybabies who should obey us. Which is it? And you've got Hitler backwards: he wanted to conquer neighbors for their land and resources, called Lebensraum, and historians note he pointed to America's conquest of the West as a model. "Canada to Chile" with their resources working for us IS that idea. Returning stolen land is the opposite.
And "Crazy people belong in jail" skips how people get there: trauma, poverty, abuse, war, addiction. About 1 in 5 US adults has a mental illness in a given year. That's not a separate class of people, it's our families. People with serious mental illness are more likely to be victims of violence than perpetrators. And Mark 5: a man lived in chains among the tombs. Jesus didn't lock him up. He healed him, "clothed, and in his right mind."
What was the reasoning behind Anschluss? Jesus can heal those but we are not God neither are scientists or doctors. We do invest in other nations through the UN as we make 22% of all their funding. But they are also funded by our largest enemy china so they are not going to have our best interest always.
Here's why I keep answering with care instead of insults. Authoritarian thinking isn't a sign someone's broken; research shows fear and threat can pull anyone toward it. You lost family to violence, and I understand why control feels like safety. But meeting cruelty with more control, more jails, more conquest, doesn't end it. It spreads it. That's why I won't call you subhuman or say you belong in a cage. That's the cycle I'm trying to break.
I never said you are subhuman or belong in a cage. I think those that commit crimes belong in jails regardless of their mental status. I think that if countries are so bad that everyone wants to come here we have a moral obligation to fix the country and the most effective way is full integration.
You moved from "crazy people belong in jail" to "if they commit a crime." Different claim. And jail doesn't fix crime, it holds it. The US has one of the highest incarceration rates on earth, and about 2 in 3 people released from state prison are rearrested within 3 years. Prevention works better: treatment, housing, stability before a crisis. And Rom 3:23: all have sinned. If wrongdoing meant a cage, we'd all be in one. Grace is the point.
And prison often makes it worse. Researchers call it the "school of crime" effect: people go in for something minor and come out with new skills, gang ties, and a record that shuts them out of jobs. Major reviews of the research find incarceration doesn't reduce reoffending and may increase it. Prison gangs recruit inside, and MS-13 grew stronger through US prisons too. If you want fewer gangs and cartels, cages are feeding them.
Crazy people are murderers and rapists. Not saying crazy ppl as those with mental illnesses like depression Altho the two can be the same. Jails have rehabilitation programs and facilities but it’s also a culture conversation for those that go to jail why they get incarcerated and put back but that’s a different topic.
So "crazy" now means murderers and rapists, not mental illness. Then we agree more than it seemed: people who commit violence should be held accountable, and mentally ill people shouldn't be lumped in with them. You also just said why people keep ending up back in jail is a conversation worth having. That's the point I've been making all along. I'll leave it there.
Research shows the opposite. Stricter, more isolating prisons produce more reoffending, not less. The UN's Mandela Rules treat solitary beyond 15 days as torture, and studies link it to higher reoffending and higher death rates after release. Norway runs humane prisons focused on rehabilitation and has one of the lowest reoffending rates in the world. Harsher cages make more dangerous people. If you want fewer victims, that's backwards.
That's exactly the point: culture is a choice. Norway's prisons used to be much harsher, and it chose to reform them in the 1990s around rehabilitation. And it works here too: North Dakota studied Norway's model in 2015, cut solitary confinement dramatically, and reported fewer violent incidents inside. If "different culture" is the problem, then change the culture. That's what I've been saying all along.
Since you believe in Christ: "I was in prison, and ye came unto me" (Matt 25:36). Jesus's first sermon was to "preach deliverance to the captives" (Luke 4:18). God says He has "no pleasure in the death of the wicked; but that the wicked turn from his way and live" (Ezek 33:11). That's rehabilitation. The thief on the cross got paradise, not a harsher cell. And Paul helped kill Christians before God redeemed him. Scripture bets on change, not cages.
It takes precedent because Jesus is the fulfillment of the second covenant given to the Jews by God through Moses as well as the first, given to Abraham, who then became Israel. Jesus’ words, are over that of the Old Testament entirely due to this fulfillment of the covenants. Furthermore, by any Christian standard, including evangelicals,Jesus‘s word, would trump that of the Old Testament even without the understanding of the covenant as we all believe that he is the way to seek God and heaven.
By the law, most scholars agree and most sectors agree that the law he is referring to is the covenants. Also by that standards do you eat shrimp, wear mixed fabrics, work on Saturdays, or not keep kosher? Because then you have already broken God‘s law and buy your own logic are far removed from his grace, as if Jesus is not trumping the words and laws in the Old Testament. We must still keep to the Jewish standards.
My point wasn't that Christians have to keep kosher. It's that love for the stranger survives either way. Jesus said the whole law hangs on loving God and neighbor (Matt 22:40), Paul said it's fulfilled in "love thy neighbour" (Gal 5:14), and when asked who our neighbor is, Jesus answered with a Samaritan, a foreigner (Luke 10). Jewish tradition counts the command to protect the stranger 36 times in Torah. Whatever takes precedence, the answer's the same.
Apologies I thought you were the other guy and I saw Leviticus and just lost my shit because usually every time Leviticus is brought up it’s with some bullshit. I agree with you there I think if we were really a “ Christian nation” (which we are not as we have the first amendment) we would be taking care of immigrants.
No worries! I agree, but I'd go further: there's no such thing as a Christian nation. Jesus said, "My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight" (John 18:36). Anyone trying to build a Christian nation has already stepped away from Christ. That's where we keep failing: doctrine bent to serve power instead of the people Jesus served.