
___joker__
Liberalism started out as a revolutionary ideology, you fucking dunce 🤦♂️ What the fuck do you think Locke was talking about in 1689?!? Like shit, did you only read Marx and forget to read back any fucking further???????im not gonna write an essay or anything lol but he had a heavy Eurocentric/Christian-centric bias which made him often devalue other cultures. he sort of saw Communism as the ultimate expression of true Christianity and so when he did address other cultures he often said things about other people needing to abandon or rise above their cultures in order to join the global proletariat
I agree that he wrote from a very particular context. I also agree that if you read Marx and only Marx, your view is going to be quite limited. However, what he observed about political economy in his particular context is foundational. Kwame Ture argues against calling Socialism a “white” thing, “Karl Marx did not invent socialism. If I’m sitting in Libya, in the desert, and I’m doing any research on capital and labor without ever having heard of Karl Marx, I will come to the same conclusion.”
Communism is not just Karl Marx. Reducing it to Marx ignores not only Black radical thought such as in the traditions of Fanon, Cesaire, Ture, etc., but also feminist thought in the traditions of Luxemburg, Kollontai, Davis, Zetkin, etc., as well as queer, LATAM, asian, and indigenous thinkers that stretch from the 19th century to today. Socialism is not something that belongs to one people or another, it is for everyone
He is not the whole story, though. These thinkers ground themselves in Marxist thought. They have critiques of some of his ideas, but largely his observations are applied and the proposed solution is one that they accept, proving the universality of the dynamic he exposes. If you do read Marx, I encourage you to maintain this perspective. It is a good idea to look out for things that are particular to certain contexts…
I think this is a fair thing to point out. I might say that his vision for a society beyond capitalism is primarily informed by a resolution of the contradictions inherent in capitalism. If these contradictions are resolved differently in different cultural contexts, I’d argue it’d still be socialism
I agree, thanks for speaking with me! If you’re looking to read more about Socialism and Communism, I could give you book recommendations if you like—what all have you read so far? It’s also fair if you don’t want any book recs from me. Additionally, for my own curiosity, what socialist works are you reading / planning to read?
Question for a socialist, do you consider China to be communist and/or socialist? I’m asking genuinely because I have seen some say it is and some say it isn’t. They say they’re communist and definitely have a more centralized economy than the US but does that make it socialist, and if not what makes it socialist or not socialist in your eyes?