What is the point of this? A big “gotcha libs”? We believe gender identity and biological sex are separate, especially since biological sex is not a binary either. This demonstrates a fundamental lack of understanding from the right about the principles that liberals and leftists stand on.
Nobody’s doing a gotcha moment. The simplicity of biology very easily calls out the stupidity and untruthfulness in the idea of “gender identity”. You’re either male or female, you can’t change your biology, and will always be a male or female. The reaction that I’ve gained from this post shows me plenty of the lefts “viewpoints” and stances.
You’ve just described a “gotcha” moment. And also, it’s clear to me that you don’t know anything about biology if you’ve described it as simple. Sex determination especially can be rife with errors, and if there’s no such thing as a separate gender identity from biological sex, then what do you say about people with Klinefelters Syndrome? Or de la Chapelle? Or Swyer syndrome?
So much can go wrong with sex determination that to me it’d be unreasonable to claim that gender identity is solely dictated by biological sex. Unless you want to say that people with Klinefelters Syndrome are Klinefeltergender, of course. But I doubt you’re the type of person interested in discussing neopronouns.