
He became part of the foundation after he had already begun his research on China. Why, I do suppose seeing horrible things done in the name of communism might make you biased against it. But again, multiple other reports from independent experts and human rights organizations have affirmed what he’s saying. People you don’t like can be right about things.
They have affirmed the existence of human rights violations including population control, which the post is about. The BBC article does not mention genocide either. For instance in the report they talk about interviewing multiple women who were victims of forced sterilization and state these witness testimonies are credible. You can go through the report for yourself to find the evidence they independently gathered.
That’s not true. Turkey, Bosnia-Herzegovina, Somalia and Albania have all expressed concerns about the human rights situation in Xinjiang, and signed a joint statement at the UN calling for China to respect human rights and for creating a UN mechanism to monitor the rights of the people there. https://www.hrw.org/news/2020/10/06/39-countries-un-express-grave-concerns-about-chinas-abuses
You’ve made things up multiple times. You said the report referenced was by Radio free Asia, it wasn’t. You’re baffled a researcher who sees terrible things done in the name of communism might develop negative feelings towards communism, all right. You said no Muslim country believes the accusations, clearly they do or they wouldn’t sign joint statements expressing concerns about arbitrary detentions, forced sterilizations, and legal restrictions.
Expressing concern doesn’t mean these accusations are believed lmao. Radio free Asia was one of the first to publish Zenz nonsense, hence the reference. Let’s not pretend his “research” wasn’t supported by anti-communist orgs and US funding before he ever worked for the “Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation”. This propaganda isn’t even remotely disguised and yet people buy into it unquestioningly. He also started this work around the same time his accusations came out.
1. How is saying “I am concerned about these bad things that are happening” not believing the accusations? What is there to be concerned about if you don’t believe the reports are at the very least partially true? 2. Thw reports were also published by Istiqlal, BBC, and The New York Times, around the same time. 3. Adrian Zenz published his first report on the issue in 2018. he only became part of the VOC foundation a year later. And i don’t think his stance has really changed since 2018.
/1 They didn’t say “we are concerned if these allegations are true.” Here is what the statement they all signed says: “We are gravely concerned about the human rights situation in the People’s Republic of China, especially the ongoing human rights violations of Uyghurs and other predominantly Muslim minorities in Xinjiang.”
/2 „The release of the recent UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) Assessment of human rights concerns in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region, People’s Republic of China, corroborates these concerns in an impartial and objective manner. The assessment finds that the scale of the arbitrary and discriminatory detention of Uyghurs and other predominantly Muslim minorities in Xinjiang “may constitute international crimes, in particular crimes against humanity”.”
1. Refer to my other comment, concern IF the accusations are true does not mean “we think these are true” 2. Yes his reports were published, that doesn’t mean they are true. 3. The US state department immediately used reports by Zenz in their anti-China efforts. This is because these reports are US propaganda.
1. Where do they insinuate the reports might not be true? 2. Stupid to complain about rfa publishing something when they weren’t even the main ones. 3. That says nothing about whether the official reports are true or not. This is like saying because Al Jazeera reports on Israel the accusations of genocide is a propaganda initiative by Qatar
1. So when someone says “the scale of the arbitrary arrests may constitute a crime against humanity” are they saying there is maybe arbitrary arrests or maybe crimes against humanity? 2. Don’t see why you’re harping on them 3. Yes it is. Al Jazeera Media Network is owned by QMC, the official state broadcaster of the Qatari government. It is absolutely funded and owned by the government. What are you even talking about
1. You conveniently forgot that’s not the full quote (…) is doing some heavy lifting. 2. They are a state department propaganda program lol. 3. I meant the U.S. state department. Big difference. The world’s most powerful western power funding sources and studies is vastly different.
It WOULD constitute it if it was confirmed. If this was 100 percent confirmed that the detentions were motivated by ethnic and religious suppression they wouldn’t have bothered to use “may”. They would say “this constitutes”. The arrests exist (anti terrorism efforts ramped up after attacks in 2016), the reason is what’s disputed, and there is no proof they are for that purpose.
/1 „Even taking into account the overall decline in birth rates in China, these figures remain unusual and stark. The same applies to the figures regarding sterilisations and IUD placements in XUAR, with official data indicating an unusually sharp rise in both forms of procedures in the region during 2017 and 2018, in comparison with the rest of China.”
/3 While the high birth rates among Uyghurs and other Muslim ethnic minorities prior to 2017 can partially be attributed to less strict implementation of family planning policies before that time, 254 a number of other factors credibly contribute to this significant and rapid drop in birth rates. The Government states that it conforms with broader global trends, as urbanization and modernization lower birth and death rates
They remain “unusual and stark” because the region caught up in development with the rest of China, whose rates are already low. You think China would have published IUD data if they were actually sterilizing people?? Lmao that data was published because it doesn’t show anything actually suspicious.
There were a lot of images and data about Xinjiang that were leaked like the Xinjiang police files. If the government won’t ever release it why do you demand statistical evidence? According to you we literally can’t have it unless it was leaked so if that doesn’t happen how can you demand statistical evidence but also believe it’s impossible to get it?
1. Have you actually looked through them? AI slop photos claiming to be mugshots lmao. Plus even if they were authentic, it does nothing to demonstrate crimes against humanity. 2. I’m demanding evidence because I’m not going to take these claims on faith. If you cannot find it because it’s hard (or doesn’t exist) that is your problem.
Yes I think you’re a moron. 1. Implying the report was from Radio free Asia when it wasn’t 2. claiming I didn’t give you the full quote when I did 3. Claiming no Muslim majority countries believed the accusations and then transitioning to “they’re just repeating what the report said” implying they believe the report