Yik Yak icon
Join communities on Yik Yak Download
The assumptions we use when arguing can impact the way we debate. Assuming that AI is safe at all is not a reasonable assumption. I think you’re starting from false premises. AI should be banned
AI as a commodity is loosely regulated yet allows for some decentralization (not actively being pursued by the big AI corporations) and AI as a utility means greater regulation and centralization Would AI be safer as a commodity or a gov-owned utility?
#poll
AI as a commodity
AI as a utility
26 votes
upvote 6 downvote

default user profile icon
Anonymous 1d

You had me until "AI should be banned." You're right that premises matter, but you can't call out false premises and then assume your own. "AI is unsafe, period" isn't settled either. Risks like deepfakes, surveillance, job displacement, concentrated power are real, but "AI is an existential threat only we can manage" is a story the big labs push themselves, because it justifies rules that only giant companies can afford to follow.

upvote 5 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous 1d

OOP here, you’re exactly the kind of response I was looking for. I made the assumption AI is inevitable because that’s how futurists portray it despite its well known flaws and potentially society ending impact

upvote -1 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 1d

The real false premise in the original post is that centralized AI is automatically safer. Centralizing AI doesn't remove the risk, it just puts it all in one place. A few corporations, or one government, deciding what models can say, who gets access and what data gets collected is a safety problem too. Decentralized, locally run AI means no single point of failure, no single point of control, and no one company collecting everyone's prompts.

upvote 3 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 1d

And forget whether AI *should* be banned. Ask yourself *how* you would even do it? Open-weight models are already saved on countless hard drives and run on consumer GPUs and even laptops. You can't un-release them. A ban wouldn't stop AI. It would push it underground and leave legal access only to governments and the corporations that lobbied for the ban.

upvote 5 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 1d

So the real question isn't ban vs. no ban. It's who controls it. Regulate the harmful uses (deepfake fraud, surveillance, discrimination), require transparency, and fund public and open alternatives. Being afraid of AI makes sense, but policy driven by fear usually ends up protecting whoever's already on top.

upvote 2 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #1 1d

Yes, thank you for this. I appreciate it. I didn’t actually notice the falseness of my own assumption. I forgot that decentralized AI was a possibility - and I do agree, giving more power to people and less power to corporations is a good idea

upvote 6 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> OP 1d

Of course! I’ve been studying computer science for over 10 years, and focusing on the sociology of human-computer interaction for the past 4, so I’m always happy to share my insights

upvote 4 downvote
default user profile icon
Anonymous replying to -> #2 1d

You're thinking in black and white. Your poll gave two options, commodity or gov utility, as if those were the only choices. Now it's "inevitable" vs. "society-ending." Reality isn't a toggle switch. AI isn't one monolithic thing, its risks depend on who controls it and how it's used, and the answer is somewhere in the gray. Also, I replied to your poll directly and you skipped right past it. Worth a read before you pick another binary.

upvote 8 downvote