I almost agree with your argument in spirit, just not in context. You’re comparing two categories unrelated in every way aside from being called holidays. You’re taking religiously and/or culturally significant holidays and comparing them to a day named after some guy who didn’t discover anything and killed countless native Americans. They aren’t comparable. Besides, nobody’s censoring or repressing anything by changing the name of the day to Indigenous Peoples Day. If anything, that-
You’re all doing better. Some of you have made close to valid points to which I have refuted them. Calling names, insults, and an racial stereotyping still do not stand as arguments or even parts of arguments. I applaud the legitimate conversation, (or fragments thereof,) keep on pushing Sisyphus.
That changes nothing as I could claim hyper-specific offense about the others. Not saying he was a saint, but neither are the Macabees, or the person who created a phony holiday no one’s really sure of, nor was Muhommed as he killed many more. If I’m offended by Moslemism, should we ban their celebrations? By no means!
1) kwanzaa is a real holiday and it’s honestly pretty racist of you to call it a “phony holiday no one’s really sure of” and 2) it’s islam, not “moslemism” that’s not a real word. it’s also funny how you only mentioned holidays that are associated with minorities but not easter or christmas or some other christian holiday
First of all, nobody mentioned religion. Second of all, Hanukkah is hardly about the Macabees or the revolt. It has far more to do with retaking Judea for the Jewish and the re-dedication of the Second Temple. By that logic, you agree that the focus should be taken off Columbus and put onto Indigenous People (a shift from the person to the significance)
Replying to #2’s rebuttal: Yes I agree that banning Christian holidays would be profoundly harmful to ALL Cultures, not just the ignorant 1's. I don't se how anything I said was racist seeing as Moslemism is a multiracial religion. It may be backwards, but that's no reason assume all Mussulmen are 1 race or nation. They're not a Seracens or Osmans. There are Berbers, Bendunies, Tartars, and countless other sorts.
Response to #3’s 2 statements:Mahommed, is the The Founder of Moslemism, has gallons of 🩸 on his hands, and has a holiday in his honor. Columbus is the founder of our continent, has gallons of 🩸 on his hands(albeit quite a bit less than the former,) and has a holiday in his honor. I know not what your non sequiturs concerning other possible holidays are. My point about censorship and repression, regardless of its perceived “moral goodness“, personal “offense”, and stupidity, still stands.
You don’t need #2 to respond for you to look stupid so I’m gonna step in. 1) You’ve already been corrected on the term Moslemism and while it is a real word, it’s very archaic, as is Mussulman, stop being a pretentious weirdo acting like they were born in the wrong era. 2) The thing #2 called you racist for was a dismissal of a holiday which seemed to be Kwanzaa based on an offensive description, not anything to do with Islam. If the ambiguous holiday you referenced is Islamic, please name it.
Again to #3: Kwanza, Isn’t real. As much as I applaud its good Swahili roots, the # of people who celebrate it I can count on 1 hand. Addition, It’s basically ment for Americans to do some Swahili 🎄 stuff, dress up and feel like “Africans connected to their roots”, while sipping champagne and eating sushi. If they want to be African, they should go live in Addis for a few years, learn Ge’ez. Maybe then.
You’re so rich that you have commas to spare. Since you feel the need to speak with a certain « je ne sais quoi, » please allow me to break down some of your mistakes: The first sentence comma should be after country or you could remove the word and keep the comma. Second sentence has an unnecessary comma since you’re ending a sentence in a dependent clause. You’re also missing a subordinating conjunction. The slash is wrong because it doesn’t replace the word “and” in proper English, only “or”
He never even set foot in what’s now the US, the closest he got was the Caribbean. He didn’t found anything either, other than the two small settlements he established, both of which failed due to disease, native conflicts, and poor leadership. There is genuinely nothing about the guy worth celebrating/recognizing