Well the Catholic position is that abortion is evil and the murder of children. So ofc seeing a sign promoting abortion isnât exactly the best sight to see for them
-6
Anonymous#19w
Maybe the modern catholic position is, regardless itâs just crazy to me how much they try to intervene in politics with their fairy tales
7
AnonymousOP9w
Thatâs been the Catholic position since its founding in 33AD. And they have the same right to political intervention as an atheist. Some people just had conviction man
-1
Anonymous#19w
They donât have a right to instill religious laws actually lmao. Thatâs their position.
5
AnonymousOP9w
Opposing abortion isnât a specifically Catholic policy. Many atheists and Muslims are also anti-abortion. The Catholic Church is just the biggest one in the west
1
Anonymous#19w
Sure not inherently, their reason is.
1
AnonymousOP9w
Itâs still a perfectly legal law to install. They can support it regardless of their reasoning
0
Anonymous#19w
But theyâre wrong so đ¤ˇ
10
Anonymous#29w
Maybe to you
1
Anonymous#19w
My position is the one supported by reality. I donât have to give a belief equal treatment when itâs wrong. Yeah they believe that. Theyâre wrong.
8
Anonymous#19w
They cannot propose legislation built off rellgion.
1
Anonymous#19w
So does that make god evil because he killed 2.4 million people with the great flood
9
Anonymous#19w
Catholicism has sanctioned murder for centuries. Fuck em.
3
Anonymous#29w
It can be easily argued that their position is backed by science. Whatâs objective about your opinion
0
AnonymousOP9w
Brother, yes they can. Thatâs not how separation of church and state works
0
Anonymous#19w
No it canât
1
Anonymous#29w
The argument is always life starts at conception which is true
0
Anonymous#19w
Yes it is?
1
AnonymousOP9w
No itâs not lmao. You can support and implement legislation even if your motivations are from religious reasons as long as the law can be defended with secular rationale. To which abortion can be defended in such a way
0
Anonymous#19w
âdefended with secular rationaleâ Thatâs the point, itâs not being defended with secular rationale
1
AnonymousOP9w
Yeah it is because the argument is that life begins at conception so therefore abortion is killing a human. Thats fully defensible
1
Anonymous#19w
Killing a human isnât a crime. Illegally killing one is.
1
AnonymousOP9w
That doesnât disprove the fact that this law can be secularly defended. If you think itâs morally wrong to kill a baby in the womb then thatâs defensible
1
Anonymous#19w
And a catholics reasoning why itâs morally wrong would likely be because..?
1
AnonymousOP9w
A Catholics reasoning is that murder is a grave sin. Yes, absolutely. An Atheist, Muslim, Jew could all agree with that moral sentiment for either religious or non-religious reasons. It absolutely holds up in the judiciary system
1
Anonymous#19w
So if they were to implement a law saying something should be outlawed because of the religiously given moral implications?
1
AnonymousOP9w
It really depends. Like if someone attempted to implement a law banning eating meat on Fridays for lent, that would not hold up because it canât be defended secularly.
Banning abortion can be defended from religious or secular moral reasons like Iâve said
1
Anonymous#19w
Using religious reasoning, if someone were to propose a law banning something, would that be upheld legally?
1
AnonymousOP9w
If it can be defended with secular rationale as well yes it would
0
Anonymous#19w
âUsing religious reasoningâ
1
AnonymousOP9w
This is a matter of semantics. Yes, the reasoning being fully religious is irrelevant
-1
Anonymous#19w
Semantics is doing a lot of heavy lifting when this is the same scrutiny any legal entity would ask.
1
AnonymousOP9w
Not really the point I was making when I said this is a matter of semantics. But literally any site about laws and the first amendment would agree with what Iâm saying
1
Anonymous#19w
Completely untrue lol
1
AnonymousOP9w
Actually thereâs a SCOTUS case now that Iâm further looking. McGowan v. Maryland actually shows that the Establishment clause doesnât invalidate laws just because they were supported for religious reasons
1
AnonymousOP9w
I guess it is true after all
1
Anonymous#19w
Youâre just saying this lol
1
AnonymousOP9w
Look it up bruh
1
Anonymous#19w
Me look it up after you tried arguing that me asking for reasoning is semantics?
1
AnonymousOP9w
No I was saying that the debate was going nowhere for like 5 replies because of a semantics issue
1
AnonymousOP9w
Or yk what maybe I fucked up the usage of the word semantics. But either way the SCOTUS case proves what Iâm saying. Laws with religious backing do not violate the Establishment clause provided they have secular reasoning