
Sure dude, if that’s your stance then surely you can condemn the Vietnamese for using their civilians “as shields” against the Americans during the Vietnam war? Being entirely technologically and militarily outmatched they should’ve just faced their invaders in open fields and gotten annihilated right? Or just had the decency to surrender as soon as people invaded their country? It’s certainly their fault that the us chose to butcher so many civilians to get what they wanted
Brainwashed moron exhibit A. The genocide has been happening way before October 7 btw. What a coincidence that all schools, mosques, and hospitals are being targeted. But Hamas has tunnels under the ENTIRE city right? I’m also curious to see how you justify Israeli “settlers” in the West Bank who harass Palestinian villages unprovoked, and kill press, just to steal Palestinian land there as well. No Hamas in the West Bank so why are they encroaching there? 🤔
Yes. Hamas should surrender. If an organization uses civilians as hostages it is inherently evil. And Viet cong soldiers were not militarily outmatched. They were an experienced fighting force who had already defeated French and Chinese forces. Their use of guerrilla warfare was masterclass.
I mean let’s unpack this then, you seem to be contradicting yourself. First, the Vietcong were technologically and militarily outmatched, they had inferior weapons and technology. To make up for that they had to fight in and around the towns they were defending. In close proximity to civilians. The Americans, using the same arguments the Israelis are, responded by massacring entire villages and destroying forests with toxic chemicals.
So the question is, what do you really believe? Should Hamas and the Vietcong have immediately surrendered once they realized they were militarily outgunned and that the stronger invading forces will massacre their civilians to get at the soldiers? Or do the people being invaded have a right to use guerrilla warfare? And in that case, do we feel capable of condemning the stronger invaders for massacring civilians when they don’t need to?
You don’t really get to pick and choose which imperialists to condemn when the dynamics are the same. You have the privilege of time having passed to look back at Vietnam with different eyes. Back then you would’ve condemned the Vietcong as terrorists using civilians as human shields. 30 years from now you’ll be able to condemn the Israeli invasion for what it is. Such is the conservative way
I do condemn the Vietcong using civilians as shields. But that wasn’t their primary war strategy. One is fought in a jungle with no choice but to fight. The other is in a dense city with a choice to not fight. Hamas is the aggressor. Israel is defending itself. That’s the primary difference. Any military has the choice to use civilians as hostages. The reason they don’t is because it’s naturally evil. Hamas has no issue with it though.
What do you mean that wasn’t their primary strategy? The Vietcong fought in and around the villages they were trying to defend and as a result the us destroyed those villages and forests. As well as many of the people in them. That is what you would call using humans as shields, because they’re in close proximity with civilians. Combatants without advanced weapons and logistics don’t have the option to fight anywhere else, it’s that or surrender.
And how did either the Vietcong or Hamas have the option to not fight? They can fight to ward off invaders or they can surrender and be invaded. Like the Ukrainians in their current war, the Vietcong and Palestinians chose to fight. Hopefully you’ll remember that Israel has been engaged in hostile occupation since long before October 7th.
Occupying someone else’s territory is what we call an offensive move, which is the opposite of defensive. Until Israel fully leaves the land they are occupying, the people being occupied will fight to throw off their oppressors. It is Israel and Israel alone who makes the violence continue. Which is exactly what they want by the way, they’re counting on people like you to consume their storytelling and back their genocide
We can take this to the Assyrian empire. Israel is retaliating because Hamas launched missiles. Hamas launched missiles because it was blockaded. And Israel probably had a good reason to enforce the blockade. It goes back and back. We can only look at this from the current modern perspective. Hamas is using civilian shields. Hamas deliberately targeted innocent civilians in the missile strikes. They are terrorists who kill civilians, nothing more.
It seems like you are suggesting that there is some world in which peace is achieved by Hamas surrendering and allowing Israel to occupy Palestine. How could you possibly expect that? Would you similarly expect there to be peace if Ukraine would only allow Russia to occupy their land? Disarm and let Russia occupy then talk peace later? How would that work? The aggressor needs to be stopped, that’s Russia and Israel.
Because you can’t really point to an unprovoked action by Hamas. Everything you’ve mentioned is them trying to throw off Israel because it’s happened while Israel was blockading them, stealing their land, executing and abducting their civilians…etc. Israel is very advanced militarily, they could easily defend their border if that was their goal. Makes you wonder why they let October 7th happen, why might they want a very visible terrorist attack to take place?