
justinian
I love the United States 🇺🇸 <3 I want Americans to live better lives and have more freedom and prosperityLol. Ironically, I’m a medical student. There’s a reason the best doctors from all those countries want to come here, and it’s much harder to match to residency here if you’re from those countries. Plus, even if they did residency in that country and are fly trained, they’re forced to do it again here because their training is seen as “subpar.”
The reason people want to come to America is because we’ve ravaged most of the rest of the world with imperialism, dingus. You get more money here. It’s not a commendation of our medical system. It’s the pragmatic choice with the benefit of shorting those other nations of talented people
There are only certain hospitals that are for-profit. All HCAs for example. Trust me, none of us want to do residency at those hospitals if we can help it. Academic places aren’t. But again, the main problem is money hungry administrators. I will completely agree with you on that.
this is literally wrong wtf. foreign doctors don’t have to redo residency here because their training is “subpar,” it’s just that every country’s system is different and the u.s. wants everyone standardized for legal and insurance reasons. it’s also harder for international grads to match because of limited slots and visa stuff. some of the best doctors i’ve worked with were foreign-trained.
nothing magically justifies a system that bankrupts people because they don’t live a perfect lifestyle. plenty of other countries have world-class medicine and universal access without drowning people in bills. stop confusing shiny equipment and massive bills with quality healthcare.
Yeah for “standardization and insurance reasons” because insurance here views their training as subpar. Because it is. You know it and I know it. Some foreign doctors are great, yes. But a lot are terrible. Aka one of the doctors I scribed for. Most train at shitty hospitals that no US graduate wants to go to.
I clearly already mentioned all of those factors if you’d just read. Bloated money hungry admin is the source for 99% of why our healthcare is so expensive. To the point where if every doctor worked for free, it’d only drop spending by ~8%. Calm the fuck down. I agree with you on that.
no, that’s not how it works. insurance companies don’t decide who’s “qualified”. licensing boards and medical councils do. the reason foreign doctors redo residency isn’t because their training is “bad,” it’s because the u.s. doesn’t have reciprocal agreements with other countries’ medical boards.
saying “most train at shitty hospitals no us grad wants” is just arrogant and wrong. tons of international hospitals produce physicians who are just as competent, often more experienced, because they see higher patient loads and more complex cases. the u.s. literally relies on them; about a third of doctors here are foreign-trained. if their training were actually “subpar,” american healthcare would collapse overnight
Dude. It’s bad. It’s why most don’t land at big academic institutions, but instead at shitty for-profit hospitals. In academic circles their training is seen as inferior which is why you don’t see them taking up many coveted residency positions unless they’re from Oxford or something. That and their board scores just aren’t good enough.
no i don’t know why you keep saying that these foreign doctors are bad, are you racist or something? they end up in these shitty hospitals because the u.s. system makes it insanely hard for them to get visas, funding, or match spots at academic centers, no matter how good they are. residency selection isn’t some pure meritocracy, it’s loaded with bureaucracy, nepotism, and institutional bias toward u.s. grads.
I don’t know why you’re yelling at me when this is just the common sentiment at most academic medical centers. Their board scores suck on average compared to US grads, and they typically don’t have as standardized undergraduate medial education as us. Not trying to be mean but it’s just the common sentiment at these big academic places. Add that on top of the Visa requirements and hoops extra hoops to jump through, they don’t want to take a chance on them. Sucks, but it is what it is.
you’re literally just cherry picking a stat to fit your narrative. first of all, that only represents newly matched residents, not the entire physician workforce. second of all, do you understand why they only take up 19% of first year residency slots? bc again, visa issues, citizenship bias, and funding limits. multiple studies show IMGs actually have equal or better patient outcomes than u.s.-trained doctors, particularly in internal medicine and primary care. look that up.
nah, i’m just not letting your lazy stereotypes slide. if you’re gonna be a doctor then you should know this shit, you’re making bs generalizations about your future patients and colleagues. board scores mostly reflect access to resources, not ability. IMGs take the same exams without the tutoring and support U.S. students get. and plenty of them come from world-class schools like oxford, mcgill, or aiims. the “non-standardized education” line is just american gatekeeping.
lol okay? do you know what medical discrimination is? do you know that women's healthcare is far from the level of men's healthcare? do you know that doctors used to think black women didnt feel as much as white women, leading to them not getting the pain meds they need? and how that still affects care today? or do you just not care lol lol
You’re bringing up shit from the Henrietta Lacks days” dude she died less than 100 years ago and seeing as HeLa cells are STILL being used without consent or compensation framing that story like it’s from 1432 CE or smth and not a relatively recent example of problems that still exist is really disingenuous