
i don't see why you Have to write someone neurotypical, then, or even think of it in those terms; neurotypical and neurodivergent aren't the two options of a binary but a spectrum as well. so—and not to be cliche—maybe just write the characters as characters first and then tweak them as you deem fit to best serve your story. if that means toning down some of qualities of theirs, then you start looking at it from that lens.
I literally have the same problem. I would suggest writing a list of things that a neurotypical person would not say or do, and once you are editing your page, look at the actions, behaviors, and quotes from your character and compare it to the list. If they are in conflict, take those things out and replace them with a secondary list: this list is of things a neurotypical person WOULD do and say. I hope this helps! If you find yourself stuck, I can help you write the two lists.
“Hello. I am normal,” said Sathington in a normal and even tone. “Football is a thing I enjoy. Here are the names of many teams, past and present.” Sathington proceeded then to displayed his well-adjusted social demeanor by listing—as promised—several dozen franchises. The bouncer, being impressed, let him into the Popular People Drinking Bar.
of course, this is very general advice so take it with a grain of salt, especially if your story is very much about the neurotypical character(s) BEING neurotypical, or maybe about how your neurodivergent character(s) interact with your more neurotypical character(s), and we're very much involved in their headspaces as readers. but even then 🤔
i ask bc i’m trying to write my nd characters’ struggles with trying to communicate thoughts and opinions with their neurotypical loved ones. i’m trying to model it after interactions i’ve had with other neurotypical people, but it always feels off, so i try to modify it later, but then i realize everyone feels neurodivergent but in conflicting ways. i think i have an idea how to make the scenes work better tho thanks to other people’s suggestions! :D
yaaay i'm glad you got some ideas 🥳 and with your case it sounds like another thing that might help would be reaching out to neurotypical people you know (or anyone who might have a handle on this really) and having them beta-read to see if it's coming off as intended!! i know for me sometimes i feel like i'm not doing enough in some certain respect but it turns out it's fine or only needs minor tweaking lol