Because people who identify with the incel mentality are not “involuntarily celibate” it hasn’t meant that for a while. People who call themselves incels and identify with it are people who just hate women. They hate women, they blame women, the ones who are threatening to harm us and hurt us. That is what an incel means.
There’s a difference between just being a virgin and being an incel. Most women, I won’t say all because I’m sure there’s some who don’t think this way, don’t care if you’re a virgin or not. But when you call yourself an incel, you’re aligning yourself with an extremely misogynistic group that is known for being awful to women. Shockingly, women don’t like that very much. A lot of self proclaimed incels aren’t virgins because they’re awful looking, they’re virgins because they talk to women-
most guy virgins prolly aren’t virgins by choice. you don’t need to identify with a group that’s so obviously problematic. you have to understand social contexts here. no one cares if you’re struggling to get laid or weird or awkward. no one hates you for that. we hate the ones who are consumed with hatred and jealousy of women, the ones who spread hateful or innacurate messages and are just entirely miserable
if you find yourself slipping into that category of resenting women, being nasty online and overall buying into incel rhetoric then you needa check yourself but if you’re a genuinely good guy then women don’t hate you. they may not be attracted to you or wanna date you but that’s not hate
That’s a good question. You should have safe spaces to talk about this, reflect on it, learn from it, and better understand yourself. I think that bad people have kind of ruined the word “incel”, and identifying as one will likely take you into an environment that is far from safe and supportive.
A similar thing happened to the word “feminism”. It started out as simply a person who believes in gender equality and participates in activism, but many people today believe it is about hating or dominating men. So what do we do, if we want to advocate for women to go to school in Afghanistan? Do we reclaim “feminism” or pick a new word?
What do you think you should do with the term “incel”? Could go either way. Convincing women to like people who call themselves incels might be difficult. But calling yourself an incel will appeal to other incels. People falling into that hate trap could join your supportive incel community instead of gravitating to hateful content.
Hate is a strong word. I think anyone is justified in AVOIDING people or being suspicious of them, but genuinely hating people for no reason other than gender is never justified. Also, there are narcissistic men and narcissistic women, and narcissists of both sexes are more predisposed to see their sex as superior. There are genuinely bad people among both feminist and incel circles who are there specifically to spread sexism and fuel their egos.
Yes, they would. Narcissistic people will find the dumbest reasons to hate someone, from their hair color to their sex to their favorite movie. There absolutely would be narcissistic women claiming superiority over men and vice versa even if patriarchy never existed. Patriarchy is the only reason we have many good feminists— because there are actual reasons for feminism that lead good people to identify that way as they bring change.
A lot of the women who talk about hating all men have a history of violence/verbal abuse involving men, which is why they say that. Without the incels and other misogynistic men, I think we would see a significant decrease in the amount of these “bad feminists”. And yeah it does seem icky to compare the two because misandry exists almost exclusively on the internet and doesn’t seem to contribute to many systemic problems, where as women deal with misogyny/violence against them nearly on a daily
To be clear, I am not talking about people saying “all men are bad” on the Internet. I am talking about narcissistic women who are biased against men and show it in their everyday life. The SA survivors who want to talk bad about men online but treat their brothers and male friends with immense kindness are NOT the problem here. It’s narcissistic mothers, teachers who show favoritism toward female students, etc. Actual bias against men does exist irl, but not as widespread or entrenched as misog